This is an archive of thegodrrat, along with other rrats linked within it, edited for easier read and navigation.

Table of Contents
  1. The Grand Unified Rrat
    1. What is the Grand Unified Rrat (the God Rrat)?
    2. Why should I believe the GURRAT?
    3. Further Evidence
    4. How does this fit with other rrats?
    5. Curiosities
    6. Timeline
    7. Other write-ups, summaries, and reinterpretations
    8. Supplemental Info
    9. Archive of GUR relevant threads
  2. Niji Merch Rrat
    1. Rules of Engagement
    2. Why?
    3. The Results
    4. Conclusion
    5. The Data
  3. The Very Incomplete Nijisanji Yab List
    1. Prelude 1
    2. The Yabbening
    3. Prelude 2
    4. The Yabbening 2
  4. Ennaschizo
    1. The "Fried Chicken Incident"
    2. The "NTR Arc"
    3. The Parasocial Drama
    4. Povertybaiting
    5. The Drama Arc
    6. Miscellaneous shitty things Enna has done
    7. Enna's Clique
    8. Enna is also a complete SJW, she was doing the "fried chicken" bit for popularity
    9. Enna has been caught in numerous lies
    10. Enna being insulting towards literally everyone

The Grand Unified Rrat

archived from rentry.org/thegodrrat

Back to TOC

What is the Grand Unified Rrat (the God Rrat)?

—⠀The GURRAT is a rrat that strives to explain all of the baffling news coming out of NijiEN for the past year. The true beauty of the GURRAT, however, is in its simplicity and elegance: it's able to tie together most of the verifiable information we know from several separate instances, and crucially do so without at any point invoking shadowy unknown management characters pulling the strings, or assuming the unbelievable stupidity, cartoonish Machiavellian malice, or irrational behavior without obvious motivations that other rrats require. The core of the rrat is as follows:

> NijiEN launches in May 2021 with their first wave LazuLight. At this time, it's a small branch without dedicated staff. However, we know that at this time, members of the recently disbanded Nijisanji India branch, specifically ex-Liver Noor, were being used as EN management. (source)
> However, quickly the EN branch outgrew its small staff. Obsydia, Ethyria, Luxiem, and Noctyx debuted within less than a year. JP management couldn't speak English, and there weren't enough English-speaking staff to manage all the new talents as the popularity of the branch exploded.
> To make matters, worse in mid 2022, half the EN managers and staff left to found and subsequently bankrupt a failed NFT company (source)*. Some of the ex-IN talents were promoted further upward. Allegedly, talents were at this point effectively self-governing, avoiding involving the ineffective upper management whenever possible. By the time Xsoleil debuted in December 2022, official management had become almost vestigial, with a single 2-week-old hire as the manager for the entire branch (source: One Girl's Story, Sayu)
> *NOTE: The original source of the leak indicated that this may have happened in 2020 instead, however, the earliest available web archive of the yealabs website was from July, 2022.
> Also throughout this time, bilingual talents were being used as translators and go-betweens for the English-speaking (EN) talents to communicate with the Japanese-speaking management. (source: Sayu's interview with FalseEyeD, Feb. 5th)
> As the number of English-speaking staff decreased and the number of Livers exploded, these liaisons started to become more and more important to the operations of the branch, with EN talents having to go through them to communicate with JP upper management. Chief among these was daisenpai Elira Pendora, bilingual, who already had other friends nepo-hired to the company.
>As time goes on, to cut out the middle man of needing to constantly send things back and forth between the glacially slow JP managers via translation, more and more managerial duties are effectively delegated to these liaison talents themselves, with Elira then sub-delegating to other trusted talents (her friends). Eventually, there is effectively a shadow bureaucracy of manager-talents, headed by Elira, in charge of organizing projects, getting permissions, translating, commissioning contractors, etc.
> As a result, a natural favoritism system is established, creating a toxic work environment where talents who are on good terms with Elira and the shadow management are able to get their projects fast-tracked and those who aren't are able to be stonewalled and mired in bureaucracy unless they can speak Japanese to communicate directly with upper management.
> By the start of 2023, the year of near-constant NijiEN yabs, the insane are effectively running the asylum

—⠀So where does Selen come in?

> Selen was ambitious. She had near-constant projects and always needed to follow up with management on some commission or idea or video. She was by all accounts, at least a little bit difficult to work with, and not suited to a Japanese workplace environment or tolerant of bureaucracy. She was the most successful female talent. She was Elira's lore sister, but seemingly they didn't personally get along. She didn't participate in the secret gc stream. She can't speak Japanese and thus had to rely on the shadow management liaisons as the go-between for her numerous highly involved projects. She openly criticized management and went behind their backs to get things done. She was probably a pain in their collective asses while also being more successful than them in her streaming career.
> Throughout that time, Selen felt stifled by management and correctly recognized the obvious favoritism where others would quickly get approval for things she couldn't, or be offered sponsorships she was cut out of, despite being the biggest female Liver. She tried to work with them but constantly was stonewalled with red tape and felt singled out for special harassment. Her projects were often axed or mired in bureaucracy and delayed for no clear reason. As a result, she started going out herself to get her own permissions, sponsors, and commissions, which bothered the clique even more and caused them to turn down or sabotage her self-organized projects for not getting prior approval through them. Public hints of the same from Selen's tweets.
> Things came to a head with the Last Cup of Coffee MV, which was important to her and had been in the works for a long time, with her having to directly go chase down permissions because management wouldn't do it. When she was given the run-around once again, it was the last straw and she went rogue.
> This culminates in her multiple attempts (on her life) (source), termination, and reincarnation as Dokibird.

Why should I believe the GURRAT?

—⠀Simply put, the GURRAT explains and ties together most of the otherwise inexplicable actions of Nijisanji management. While originally intended to explain Elira's black screen stream, anons discovered that it fits together numerous pieces of otherwise confusing information.

  • Starting with the black screen stream, this gives plausible motivations for Elira's actions. Unlike other rrats—which require a cabal of 40 IQ managers holding a gun to her head to release a disastrous statement undercutting their own CEO, or Elira to be such an evil, petty psychopath that she willingly self-destructed for no discernible reason other than sheer spite—this rrat gives her multiple plausible, understandable motivations:

    > she was afraid of the contents of doki's document, which show a history of gross managerial misconduct, and was attempting to preemptively discredit it and damage control
    > caught between the public and JP management and trying to cover her own ass rather than the company's reputation
    > she was frustrated and defensive because it was her and her friends personally, not some random Japanese middle manager, who she believes doki disrespected
    > she volunteered her channel, because as a leader she should take the bullet for her own mistakes
    > JP management told her to clean up her mess
    > etc

    • It also explains how she and Vox got ahold of supposedly confidential documents, as effective management they will have been privy to it and maybe even used to translate it.
    • It explains why her, Enna, and Millie's names were specifically listed in that document; they were the most responsible for the managerial bullying
    • It explains the obviously spiteful timing of that announcement, and the tone of the contents therein, which were extremely unprofessional and would never have been something a random PR manager with no skin in the game would endorse. It explains as well how she got ahold of those screenshots without running her insane plan through actual adult managers.
    • It explains why the other talents are so assblasted about Selen giving the middle managers trouble in the first place.
    • It explains why there is such an obvious night and day difference between Elira's black screen video statement and Riku's statement, which by its tone, went through an actual PR auditing. The clashing of contents between both statements signals that Elira's and Riku's videos are not planned by the same management team with similar goals.
  • It explains how they were able to bully Selen in the first place. To bully someone you need power over them.
  • It also explains some of the oddities around the original termination statement. In particular, the bizarre wording of the following statement:

> Selen claimed that she was being harassed by other affiliated Livers due to mismanagement.

—⠀Which was the first instance of anyone mentioning bullying by Livers. Previously, it had seemed that Selen's issues were primarily with management. The statement at face value also makes little sense, as how can the Livers bully her due to mismanagement? If the Livers and the management are effectively one and the same, this all makes more sense. It also explains why they would even bring up the other Livers. It explains the clearly vindictive and unprofessional nature of the termination letter in general, as again, it feels almost personal.

  • It explains the rationale behind Millie's infamous tweet. Other rrats require Millie to be the dumbest person alive, or a sociopathic cartoonish bully, publicly taunting Selen for no reason whatsoever. Through the lens of the GURRAT though, it makes a lot more sense: she is responding out of frustration for Selen ignoring management and trying to defend management because management is her and her friends. Millie may even be the liaison replying to Selen in those screenshots released by Elira, which would make even more sense, <- most likely debunked by forensics, see the Curiosities section below.

One of the biggest strengths of the rrat is that it doesn't require projecting to ascribe motivations to anyone, any jaw-dropping stupidity, or any 4D chess. Elira could be a stone-cold bitch queen, but she could also be simply incompetent and casually nepotistic, or even a genuinely hard-working leader who thinks she's doing the right thing for her branch, and it doesn't change the rrat. Selen could be a total menhera or completely innocent, and the rrat works all the same. We don't need to know the reason Elira dislikes Selen. It could be because she's hard to work with or pure jealousy, but the rrat still works.

Further Evidence

How does this fit with other rrats?

  • The Luca skinwalking shitshow and Scarle-Aster drama:
    —⠀This explains partially the Scarle-Aster screenshots being in the possession of Luca and then Raziel and Raziel knowing about Aster harassing other Livers. If this effective self-governing system was in place, it explains why Scarle would go to Luca with her problems instead of an actual manager, because by this point, issues are now being handled internally by other talents. Luca then screenshots it to send to Raziel and ask for advice, and she leaks it with the rest of her Luca manifesto.
  • The Zaion execution
    —⠀We know that at the time of the Zaion termination, the self-management system was in place, and her termination shares many similarities with the Selen debacle. In Sayu's One Girl's Story document, she notes that one of the things she was in trouble for was going above management's head to talk to a higher manager directly, which initially makes zero sense. But when you consider the GURRAT, it starts to make sense. Sayu is Japanese and is a fluent Japanese speaker. She would be able to jump over the shadow bureaucracy and talk directly with the JP managers. This obviously ruffled feathers. Another interesting detail is that apparently, Xsoleil's branch manager was a 2-week-old hire, who was effectively a puppet of someone higher up. She says:

    > Anytime I had a call with our manager to discuss something, THEIR manager was also there. And it was pretty much just me asking him stuff while she sat there and nodded her head.

    —⠀A bizarre situation indeed.
    —⠀Zaion's termination letter, when taken at face value, reads as a hypocritical litany of purported "abuses" that other prominent members would also be guilty of if the same standard had been applied to everyone in Nijisanji EN. At the time, it seemed like NijiEN's management was leveling every possible accusation against her to justify removing her from the organization. It was also inferred that management, seemingly out of spite, was aiming to use the claims made in the termination letter to ruin her reputation as a VTuber.
    —⠀But in light of the rrat, her termination letter may also be understood as a deliberate attempt to poison the well, smearing and discrediting her before she could come to the public with incriminating information on NijiEN and the misconduct of its shadowy de facto management. As events turned out, Sayu's testimony did not even go so far as to directly implicate any of her fellow Livers in unethical practices or illicit activities. Nevertheless, her credibility was damaged by the spurious allegations made against her. Had she made specific claims about talents or managerial misconduct, the material in her termination letter would have been used to ridicule her assertions.
    (expand more on how Zaion fits in.)
  • Yugo
    —⠀(idk write something)
  • ???

Curiosities

—⠀Here are some other interesting coincidences and rrats anons have discovered. These are mostly unproven and of a more speculative nature than the main rrat, but nonetheless add some interesting context. Important to note, however, that you do not need to believe all or any of the below rrats for the main rrat to work, it stands on its own. These are merely additional bits of information to consider.

  • The Selen discord leaks
    —⠀(https://imgur.com/a/N21IQiY)
    —⠀(https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/65573885/#65608889)
    —⠀(https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/65590975/#65625101)
    —⠀On December 30th, 2023, the above screenshots, purported to be leaks from a private artists discord Selen used to organize projects, were first posted in Selen's /HAHA/ thread on /vt/. At the time, they were dismissed as obvious fakes. However, the idea from the second screenshot that the inclusion of ex-Livers was the reason for the video being made private, was considered more realistic and spread around.
    —⠀Now though, most of the information found in that second leak has been proven correct by the termination notice and the screenshots leaked by Vox in the black screen stream, despite these details not being public or widely discussed at the time of original posting. The decorations (question mark and sweat drops) were also found to identically match those on Doki's discord avatar seen in her manager Mr. Man (Sovereign)'s cow tweet.
    —⠀Following this validation, some anons remember that there was actually a first screenshot posted shortly before the second (originally on a separate thread, see below), which was considered to be too outlandish and dark to be real at the time. However, once it was recovered, we can see how the information in it closely aligns with what has since come to light. If this screenshot is real, it paints a very dark picture, and additionally puts the statement regarding graduation by Vox in new light.
    —⠀The contents of the leaks are as follows:
  1. Sometime during the making of the MV, Selen was confronted by multiple fellow NijiEN members telling her to graduate and some even further requesting her leave the company entirely "as [she] brings nothing good to the branch" or face resentment by "the majority of the people in the branch"
  2. The reason for privating the video was a new rule, which made explicit permission required from every liver present in the video ("no matter the context"), which was a problem for two reasons:
  3. Some livers demanded to not be a part of the MV after she had included them (despite knowing the disdain most had for her if 1st leak is to be trusted) because she wished for the song to be for all of NijiEN
  4. Ex-NijiEN talents were now prohibited from appearing in any form

—⠀These have the following implications

> Contrary to the leaks by Vox, the problem wasn't just that she would have to remove ex-Livers but also many current livers. She said this after the video went private and thus after the Vox leaks, which likely implies that there is missing context
> (4) might imply that the rule was only selectively kept since ex-Livers had been referenced in other recent past works
> Selen wanted to keep the MV in its original state and for it to be released on Christmas as a gift, which with above may have been what drove her to go rogue

—⠀There are two competing theories about these screenshots: one is that they are in fact exactly as described, and the second is that they may not be what they are purported to be but clearly do still contain insider information. In the 2nd case, the screenshots aren't actual discord messages by Selen in an art discord, but fabricated and leaked as a cry for help by Selen herself or someone else with insider information. Either way, the factuality of these messages or existence of this insider information is supported by posts such as this which imply artists on the project were beholden to some unofficial knowledge which they want kept private. Regardless, the sheer accuracy and unique information of the leaks over a month in advance of her termination and the discord avatar provide a strong case for the validity of the leaked messages.

>Some additional schizo ranting regarding the initial leaks: these leaks were viewed with speculation until now (of course partly due to the unlikelihood of the contents at the time), but another major reason these leaks were discredited for so long (and even still) was that new posts that included sarcastic comments like "Real leak, fake rrrrat, or AI image? You decide!" or "Look guys it 100% real!!!!" were promptly made after the first and included the same image but with a new file hash thereby effectually concealing the original ones (which are hardly if all mentioned elsewhere).
>All other threads on 4chan, reddit, etc use these new image files and reference these replies with their accompanying sarcastic comments, thereby casting strong doubt on their credibility (not to mention a distinctly abnormal tendency for posts/accounts considering the validity of these messages to be deleted(literally gone)/suspended or downvoted while the opposite is true for messages that point to the sarcastic comments or cast doubt on it).
>One might imagine these to be decoy leaks and influence on public perception being done by artists who were in the discord to cast away the leaks according to Selen's wishes to keep the info private. These are the 1st instances of "decoys" for the 1st and 2nd messages.

  • Private Discord excluding Selen and others?
    —⠀(https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhZzCBB1Ssc)
  • Millie was the manager in the screenshots leaked by Vox
    —⠀An anon believes that the person checking Selen's Last Cup of Coffee video was in fact a talent liaison, rather than a manager, and specifically that it may be Millie. Most likely now debunked.
    —⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S69014403#p69016830
    —⠀https://i.warosu.org/data/vt/img/0690/29/1707896833073534.jpg
    —⠀Several other names have been tried and been shot down with image forensics or logical deduction. This line of inquiry is most likely a nothingburger, and it's random junior staff.
  • The Canadian Manager job posting and other Niji job listings
    —⠀https://archive.ph/V6AeV
    —⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/68312666
    —⠀The above job listing was posted by Nijisanji and noticed during the initial Selen termination controversy. Viewed through the lens of the GURRAT, it has some interesting implications. Elira, as we know, just moved to Japan, and connecting these facts gives us a few options.

>the job posting is being backfilled, as Elira is being officially promoted to a higher position
>Elira has been sacked/told to stay in her lane by management following the Selen debacle and is being replaced by an official manager
>JP has taken notice of the mess that's happening in EN and is cleaning house and cracking down
>the job posting is intended as a golden parachute for a talent-manager to step back from streaming and become and official staff member

—⠀Likewise, several other Nijisanji English job postings have recently been found, which are worth considering. Some interesting bits of information in them are that they intend to pay a trilingual professional who fluently speaks three languages Japanese minimum wage: less than 8 dollars and hour, and how many of the job postings don't require English ability at all.
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69169054

  • LK
    —⠀(Expand)
  • Anonymous vent posts, presumed to be Millie
    —⠀A vent post on a sisters forum caught an anon's attention for its use of the phrase

    >management has stated that the video could still be unprivated

—⠀At the time, this had never been publicly stated, but was revealed to have been stated in the Vox slack message leaks during the black screen stream. Anons speculated that this post may have been written by Millie.
—⠀https://nyfco.org/selen-zense/comment-page-31/#comment-1006214
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/edlooYz.png
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S69036707#p69040681
—⠀Another post was suspected by an anon to be Millie due to the unique usage of 'manesan', as well as having been posted in the time between the internal Slack message asking about the song's early release and Selen's tweet about the song cover (source: NijiEn General Post) (source: Time Difference)

  • ???

Timeline

>Dec 26: Selen posts the MV, is suspended on the spot. (source: black screen stream, Vox's screenshots)
>Dec ??? (possibly 26 or 27): Selen makes an attempt on her life. (source: doki tweet)
>Dec 28: Elira makes the "health issues in my family" tweet. Some speculation this is when she found out about the suicide attempt. (source: Elira tweet)
>Dec 28–Feb 4: Selen and her lawyer go back and forth with NijiJP management trying to find a way to part amicably but it goes nowhere.
>Jan 26- dokibird seeks neutral parting (assume graduation) source doki tweet
>Feb 5 13:38 JST: Elira lands in Japan. (source: https://twitter.com/EliraPendora/status/1754363748926796123)
>Feb 5 18:00 JST: Selen's lawyer sends her document to Niji's lawyers detailing everything that was happening to her in the company, including bullying and preferential treatment.
>Feb 5 19:56 JST: Termination notice goes up. From this point on, all communication between Nijisanji and Selen, now Doki, ceases. (source: doki tweet)
>Feb ??? (possibly Feb 5 and just prior to Selen's termination): Elira is notified of the contents of the document. Whatever is inside this document SCARES her. Specifically, she is worried about her, Millie, and Enna, being doxxed, and their 'safety' being threatened. Elira later gets Vox and Ike together to record their statement for the stream. (source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o65VwnQvWW4)
>Feb 6–Feb 11: Absolute fucking chaos, but by the end, Doki just wants to move on and be done with the whole situation so she can focus on streaming.
>Feb 13: Elira drops the stream, attempting to throw Doki under the bus. Hours later, Riku prostrates himself before the masses and vows to sort out whatever the fuck is happening in NijiEN.
>Feb 14: Dokibird tweets a response to Elira's stream. (source: https://twitter.com/dokibird/status/1757763627413631383)

(if you add an event, include the source if possible)

Other write-ups, summaries, and reinterpretations

—⠀https://i.imgur.com/iqSqesl.jpeg (Elira as a 'shadow-manager / liaison')
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/jR31ib5.jpeg (Multiple summaries posted in bulk, showing the rrat's progression over time)
—⠀https://imgur.com/a/PTjXQxK (A reinterpretation of the GURRAT where Elira is just a well-intentioned wagecuck who does it for free)

Supplemental Info

—⠀Evidence, screenshot, forensics:
—⠀https://imgur.com/8HIRTo7 (NijiEN Discord leak showing Elira as the server's owner and a complete lack of management)
—⠀https://streamable.com/adcd5t (Elira confirmed she own the NijiEN discord)
—⠀https://imgur.com/a/wjs96aD (Petra accidentally leaks the NijiEN Discord)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/pP454G4.jpeg (Millie's GroupChat stream and aftermath)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/3JWt4Gj.jpeg (Compilation of Elira/Millie's suspicious behavior)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/qgh0E60.png (Post about Nova (Elira's PL) and Mint (Pomu's PL))
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/YBYWelb.png (Zaion mismanagement from One Girl's Story)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/lPczCob.png (Implying that the clique is indeed like a high school circus)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/MznEqvH.png (The uncensored top of supposed manesan's username is visible due to bad cropping)
—⠀https://imgur.com/a/zUKArNZ (Selen posts in her artists discord which reveals lots of information potentially supporting the GUR, it seems credible due to a comparison with Doki's discord avatar)
—⠀https://imgur.com/a/N21IQiY (Updated version of the above w/ older link for 1st -which doesn't include the sarcastic comment- and added link for 2nd post, also note this artist tweet implies inside knowledge? which supports credibility of these posts. Note this may be against artist's wishes)
—⠀https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ECyZ6RupPqI&t=3494s (A collab stream of Enna, Nina, Millie and Reimu on 25th June 2023 on —⠀Enna's channel, throwing shade on someone called 'Apex Predator'. Several comments said it could be referring to Reimu since she also plays Apex regularly and present in the collab, but it is most likely Selen because it happened after the art contest fiasco and Selen missing the voice pack deadline, both of them mentioned in her termination letter as damaging Anycolor's reputation)
—⠀Additional rratting, thread archives, purported insider posts:
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/6dpHLOO.png (Potential payment discrepancies)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/Sief0Sk.png (Potential insider detailing Elira's specific duties)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/IGkpVEg.png (Insider verification of Elira's nepotism)
—⠀https://i.imgur.com/eCQMHYK.png (Occam's Razor applied to mismanagement)
—⠀https://imgur.com/dMisO2o.png (Potential instances of timeline for management clique targeting Selen)
—⠀https://imgur.com/gWB03XV.png (Potential insider affirmation of clique behavior)
—⠀https://imgur.com/a/OYEi5KK (Rrat dump from several previous threads)
—⠀https://streamable.com/c7hx5c (Livers have access to other livers account)
—⠀Nijisanji Yab compilation: https://rentry.org/exx63 (to be integrated)
—⠀Enna specific Yab: https://rentry.org/rtz9g (to be integrated)

Archive of GUR relevant threads:

Paste Warosu links here - regular 4chan threads are purged after archival

—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/68996770
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69014403
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69029124
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69036707
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69041415
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69048760
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69068838
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69077250
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/68983156
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69120347
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69120405
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69142853
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69150476
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69152657
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69185316
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69150829
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69151314
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69158754
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69186816
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69210946
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69212675
—⠀https://warosu.org/vt/thread/69218120
—⠀(Be aware that Janitor(s) are deleting threads and posts that mention the GURRAT.)

the end of gurrat

Niji Merch Rrat

archived from rentry.org/nijimerchrrat

Back to TOC

Rules of Engagement

  • This list only considers internally developed and sold merch, external sponsorships and partnerships will be ignored (e.g. HYTE)
  • No Store Anniversary bundles will be considered, as they include every liver up to that point; this is irrelevant to accusations of favouritism
  • Generation/Personal merch will not be considered; most of these are released around milestones/anniversaries, and as a result are not indicative of any potential favouritism
  • Voice Packs, and bundles containing them, are separately tallied; it has been stated by (now former) NijiEN talents that they only receive 1-2% of any merch sales, with the exception of Voice Packs providing a 50% split; these represent the most economic value to talents, thus a separate tally has been kept alongside general merch presence
  • For bundles containing Voice Packs, only a few livers will recieve Key Art and appear in advertisements for the bundle; the news pages list all of the talents involved, but for the purpose of the first tally, only the Key Art livers will be considered.
  • All information for the merch considered comes from the Nijisanji EN Official Page, as a result there may be some items/bundles that are marketed/listed elsewhere, and may have been missed

Why?

One of the supplementary claims forming part of the GURRAT is an accusation that Elira, at least, benefits disproportionately as a result of a friendship/closeness with management. One of the ways this is believed to have manifested is in merch opportunities, where Elira reportedly has a majority share:
4chan post
The purpose of this document is to expand the scope of this premise, taking into account every liver, from every EN generation, for the duration of EN's activities (mostly).
Do note, however, that the results of this document are non-conclusive - one liver featuring in more bundles that others does not conclusively prove favouritism. The sample size of merch considered in this document may also preclude this document from being conclusive. This should instead serve as a supplement to other information and accusations.

The Results

Each liver is organised by generation; the prominence of each liver (most conservative reading, with no minor roles or smaller packs) is as follows:

Elira Pendora: 9 (6 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Finana Ryugu: 3 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Pomu Rainpuff: 3 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Rosemi Lovelock: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Petra Gurin: 3 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Selen Tatsuki: 4 (4 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Millie Parfait: 0
Enna Alouette: 5 (5 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Reimu Endou: 3 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Nina Kosaka: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Luca Kaneshiro: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Shu Yamino: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ike Eveland: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Vox Akuma: 4 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Mysta Rias: 3 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Sonny Brisko: 4 (4 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Uki Violeta: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Alban Knox: 3 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Fulgur Ovid: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Yugo Asuma: 0
Maria Marionette: 2 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Kyo Kaneko: 3 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Aia Amare: 3 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Aster Arcadia: 3 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Scarle Yonaguni: 4 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ren Zotto: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Doppio Dropscythe: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Meloco Kyoran: 3 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Hex Haywire: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Kotoka Torahime: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ver Vermillion: 2 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Zaion LanZa: 0
Vezalius Bandage: 0
Vantacrow Bringer: 0
Yu Q. Wilson: 2 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Kunai Nakasato: 0
Victoria Brightshield: 0
Claude Clawmark: 0

With a more generous reading (all data), the livers' appearances are as follows:

Elira Pendora: 12 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Finana Ryugu: 8 (6 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Pomu Rainpuff: 8 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Rosemi Lovelock: 12 (11 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Petra Gurin: 8 (5 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Selen Tatsuki: 9 (9 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Millie Parfait: 1 (1 of which features a Voice Pack)
Enna Alouette: 9 (8 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Reimu Endou: 8 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Nina Kosaka: 3 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Luca Kaneshiro: 9 (9 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Shu Yamino: 6 (5 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ike Eveland: 4 (4 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Vox Akuma: 5 (3 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Mysta Rias: 6 (4 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Sonny Brisko: 8 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Uki Violeta: 10 (9 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Alban Knox: 11 (11 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Fulgur Ovid: 5 (5 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Yugo Asuma: 0
Maria Marionette: 11 (10 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Kyo Kaneko: 11 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Aia Amare: 12 (9 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Aster Arcadia: 12 (11 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Scarle Yonaguni: 11 (10 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ren Zotto: 9 (9 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Doppio Dropscythe: 8 (7 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Meloco Kyoran: 10 (8 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Hex Haywire: 4 (4 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Kotoka Torahime: 7 (5 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Ver Vermillion: 7 (6 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Zaion LanZa: 0
Vezalius Bandage: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Vantacrow Bringer: 2 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Yu Q. Wilson: 3 (2 of which feature a Voice Pack)
Kunai Nakasato: 0
Victoria Brightshield: 0
Claude Clawmark: 0

Conclusion

Looking at the first set of results, which follows the same methodology as the original premise, it seems clear that there is SOME kind of bias; Elira has many more appearances than either of her gen-mates, and almost doubles the prominence of the next liver. Speaking of, Enna being second isn't all surprising, considering current rrats, though she is much closer to other livers. The only shock result is that of Millie who, by current understanding, should be a part of the clique, and thus we would expect to have any result but 0. Looking at the initial data alone, we can conclude somewhat reasonably that there IS some kind of favouritism at play.
But using a more liberal dataset, including the smaller releases and less marketed roles, the numbers start to even-out. Not only do several other livers match Elira's prominence; the number of her Voice Pack roles is middling. Under this dataset, the result is very much unclear, enough to cast doubt on the premise.
Without deeper understanding of these Voice Packs (no, I will NOT paypig), I cannot judge which dataset is more accurate. Others better acquainted with how these packs work can decide if those lesser roles are worth considering.

The Data

Below is a text dump of each bundle, organised by type of content, with a list of participants and a link to the relevant news page (minor voice roles, as outlined in the Rules of Engagement, are alternatively coloured):
GOODS AND VOICE PACKS:

Winter Date 2023: Aster, Enna
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/l4dht34uf

Halloween 2023: Dopio, Kotoka, Aia, Alban, Ver, Reimu, Kyo, Meloco, Scarle, Maria, Luca, Ren, Shu, Rosemi
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/ekwddq6v1oh4

Road Trip: Selen, Reimu, Luca, Fulgur
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/so5_o8ybx

June Bride: Nina, Vox, Ren, Scarle, Rosemi, Luca, Uki, Maria, Aster, Aia, Doppio, Hex, Meloco, Ver, Kotoka
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/dgh3m58q8g4c

Aristocrats and Servants: Alban, Sonny, Elira, Selen
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/ip84svo3m

Sakura Bloom 2023: Elira, Petra, Reimu, Aia, Shu, Uki, Aster, Luca, Alban, Doppio, Hex, Meloco, Ver, Kotoka
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/foi0_xiphed

Valentine's Day 2023: Pomu, Finana, Rosemi, Enna, Elira, Selen, Petra, Reimu, Luca, Mysta, Shu, Sonny, Fulgur, Alban, Uki, Kyo, Maria, Aster, Aia, Ren, Scarle
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/zsyyqw86pc

Winter Date 2022: Alban, Elira, Ren, Scarle
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/lbqu2df90zn

Halloween 2022: Sonny, Pomu, Elira, Finana, Selen, Nina, Enna, Luca, Mysta, Fulgur, Alban, Uki, Maria, Aster, Aia, Scarle, Ren
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/ivydqno7p

Sakura Bloom 2022: Sonny, Fulgur, Alban, Uki, Ike, Luka, Mysta, Vox, Elira, Selen, Nina, Pomu, Finana, Rosemi, Petra, Reimu, Enna
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/w3y9w8j2l

VOICE PACKS:

Party Voice: Yu Q., Aia, Aster, Ver, Vezalius, Uki, Meloco, Claude, Scarle, Selen, Doppio, Vanta, Maria, Millie, Rosemi
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/mal2beoi0k

Hero/Villain Voice: Ike, Maria, Aster, Alban, Ver, Vezalius, Meloco, Claude, Scarle, Doppio, Kunai, Vanta, Yu Q., Luca, Ren, Rosemi, Uki, Victoria, Sonny, Petra
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/q4f4skra24

Cooking Voice: Enna, Meloco, Sonny, Doppio
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/qz7ruvyzj4

Phone Call Voice: Elira, Rosemi, Enna, Vox, Kyo
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/4688h5fis

Summer Season Voice 2023: Aster, Scarle, Hex, Meloco, Pomu, Rosemi, Enna, Ike, Uki, Aia, Kyo, Maria, Ren, Doppio, Kotoka
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/ej1cotd809my

Get Well Voice 2023: Meloco, Kotoka, Doppio, Hex, Ver, Pomu, Finana, Selen, Rosemi, Reimu, Luca, Alban, Kyo, Maria, Aster, Aia, Ren, Scarle
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/29go07dou

Pampering/Scolding Voice: Shu, Luca, Selen, Enna, Pomu, Finana, Rosemi, Reimu, Sonny, Alban, Maria, Aia, Scarle, Kyo, Aster, Ren
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/0951ife4u

November Seasonal Voice 2022: Mysta, Petra, Ike, Shu, Fulgur, Alban, Uki, Kyo, Aster, Pomu, Finana, Selen, Rosemi, Maria
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/dw-0c7_fyd-v

GOODS PACKS:

HOTEL: Aia, Elira, Finana, Kyo, Ver, Yu Q.
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/jujoehgwa

Confectionary: Pomu, Elira, Finana, Scarle, Aia, Maria
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/r1ckc6xxwl

WhiteDay Gift 2023: Elira, Petra, Reimu, Vox, Mysta, Kyo
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/59en44856w6

SMALLER PACKS:

Acrylic Desk Calendar 2024: Elira, Rosemi, Aia, Meloco, Kotoka, Enna, Luka, Shu, Vox, Sonny, Kyo, Doppio
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/v0kdifd_4kb

NIJI Mascots: Elira, Uki
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/o8gzrsq8uqa

NIJI Bear vol.1: Kyo, Petra
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/l6082n2ei

Liver Outfit Goods 8th: Aster, Kotoka, Meloco
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/krh641bo8j

Liver Outfit Goods 6: Mysta
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/5kmso0t4m7i5

Liver Outfit Goods 5: Petra
https://www.nijisanji.jp/en/news/5vgid5bwv6im

the end of niji merch rrat

The Very Incomplete Nijisanji Yab List

archived from rentry.org/exx63

Back to TOC

Prelude 1

nipple controversy

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/19468346#p19470191
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/19468346#p19481936

stolen merch controversy

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1505348404271992832?s=21

stolen merch controversy 2

https://files.catbox.moe/01snms.png

cancelled sponsorships and events

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1499263704466173955
https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1605129715496296448

cancelled concerts

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1484027941994774538
https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1621003847350235137

cancelled 3D's

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1468467320574332932
https://twitter.com/nijisanji_world/status/1575328273806299136

no live2d updates in sight
discord leak revealing them seetheposting about their superior rival, marking them as jealous hololive rejects for the rest of eternity

https://files.catbox.moe/4tm32c.png
https://files.catbox.moe/qei7o8.mp4

Finana discord cancelled their b-day billboard project because she told them they're unoriginal and copying hololive

https://files.catbox.moe/p211o3.jpg

male crashing Pomu+Finana yuribait off-collabs as a "surprise"

https://files.catbox.moe/9zbe28.png

Finana openly admitting to lying about it and selling it as a "girls night" despite the male being planned all-along

https://files.catbox.moe/95urxj.jpg

comment sections getting closed to hide complaints

https://files.catbox.moe/7qnonr.png

girl streamers getting turned into accessories to the males and forced to exist just as walking collab platforms for males

https://files.catbox.moe/mj9fug.jpg

literally getting numbermogged by hololive's new INDOGS
gen2 males are a huge flop
can't get elden ring permissions
Vox fails his subathon endurance stream for 600k and cucks out after a mere 5 hours because he realizes his subs are growing too slow

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/22697963

3/4 members of Ethyria are long-time IRL friends with Elira, leading to the term "nepotism clique"
Nina exposes how the Ethyria clique literally ghosted and excluded her early on when she was trying her best to build rapport with them, and just used their own secret voice chat channels

https://streamable.com/32zdvc
https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/34666360/#34666360
https://web.archive.org/web/20220328222825/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0XktfsOoMI

Finana has a menhera meltdown on twitter about how nobody draws her in group fanart and cancels streams because of it

https://twitter.com/FinanaRyugu/status/1516160827069456386

AnyColor randomly tweets creepy vagueposts about "slander" for no apparent reason

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1515963493140344836

their chuubas keep having freudian slips about Hololive such as Alban calling Petra "Gura" accidentally or Millie saying HoloJP instead of NijiJP in a tweet, which shows what really lives rent free in their head

https://files.catbox.moe/xe9j0p.png
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hd0rZHNHUqQ

AnyColor literally goes public, to be defiled by chink investors
Kanae gets canceled for using black features to make a gorilla avatar

https://twitter.com/kanae_2434/status/1520196872744316928

Luca gets caught stealing Towa's and Okayu's copyrighted BGM music without permission or even crediting her, takes down his stream afterwards

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/23331437
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/23355496
https://files.catbox.moe/1axbvv.png

"graduation rush" trending on JP twitter because their livers keep fucking graduating one after another

https://files.catbox.moe/408b7x.png

Luxiem moving to bilibili to complete the chinkification

https://files.catbox.moe/mszd67.png

Luxiem blatantly being favored and getting more and better merch than Lazulight, causing a massive outrage

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1527454056750362624
https://twitter.com/aajjely/status/1527459595563814922
https://twitter.com/HeyGuys90973722/status/1527477091515629575
https://files.catbox.moe/8x4zbj.png
https://files.catbox.moe/b423er.jpg

Vox fujofans sending death threats to Reimu for "invading" their dating RP stream

https://files.catbox.moe/xnzj7n.png

Vox has to tell of his chink fujos for it, then immediately flip-flops and comes crawling back to them to damage control and beg them to return to him after noticing the CCV+superchat drop

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jyy_sHe8PnU

Finana jumps in during the drama with her infamous "L + Ratio you parasocial fucks" tweet (somehow this doesn't stop her from doing valentines dates and sell wedding ring merch though)

https://files.catbox.moe/q36ffe.jpg

Vox uses thumbnail art from a Taiwanese artist for his Chinese learning Duolingo stream, and literally edits in the PRC flag, causing Taiwanese fans to revolt

https://files.catbox.moe/txcd9g.png
https://files.catbox.moe/chqqs1.jpg
https://files.catbox.moe/ldefud.jpg
https://files.catbox.moe/mk5vqa.png

Nippleman suspended AGAIN

https://twitter.com/lauren_iroas/status/1535081448327487488

Yugo has a drunken menhera meltdown on-stream, genuinely sobbing and crying over not being a "real man"

https://files.catbox.moe/o83or4.mp4
https://files.catbox.moe/ga0hr1.png
https://web.archive.org/web/20220615213147/https://twitter.com/Yugo_Asuma/status/1537186081996562432

Yugo accidentally leaks discord DM's that show her manager breathing down her neck about her numbers (literally posting youtube stats)

https://files.catbox.moe/g9rg3w.png

Finana menheraposts on twitter about "trap" being a slur and bans the word, tells viewers to "educate themselves", then promptly backpedals unbans it and apologizes after backlash

https://files.catbox.moe/3079fs.png
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/27228440

Indian LGBTroon manager is caught damage controlling for Nijisanji online

https://files.catbox.moe/oz6hgg.jpg
https://files.catbox.moe/bku8o8.png

literally the only major vtuber agency to not have a booth at AX

https://files.catbox.moe/kdl9x6.png

Finana gets caught joining a fan discord server with her official account where she constantly joins vc and plays games with its members, gets bonked by management and is forced to leave it only for her to create an alt account and join again behind management's back, causing her biggest paypigs to leave her over the preferential treatment to the members of the server

https://rentry.org/fmcox
https://twitter.com/ContainmentB239/status/1547730451938168836
https://web.archive.org/web/20220714153830/https://pastebin.com/f94aCCuS

Finana's aforemention discord groomer circle leaks her Nijisanji audition tape

https://twitter.com/ContainmentB239/status/1547736242330079233
https://files.catbox.moe/z1u6id.mp4

Vox having a meltdown because internet issues caused him to lose viewers so he literally canceled and re-did the stream because it made him "feel absolutely gutted" and "lose focus"

https://files.catbox.moe/851gcq.jpg

everyone becoming more and more shameless in the coomer pandering and degenerate fetishposting both in streams and on twitter, this is literally what NijiEN is known for now
everyone getting the same copypasted shit tier merch for their birthday because Rikike doesn't want to spend a dime

https://files.catbox.moe/jvvrgw.jpg

Obsydia getting no fucking new outfits for over a year
forced to squat on the FLOOR like second-class citizens in Niji panels at CRX, wheras Hololive got premium seats

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/30259487
https://files.catbox.moe/l4y1mk.png
https://files.catbox.moe/t3qcye.png

Axia Krone having a meltdown and shitting on his own fans and consequently graduates

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IARMHF8dxbM
https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1598165201110859776

AnyColor smugly telling people on twitter they will give NO REFUNDS to NijiFES despite them axing an entire part of it specifically due to Axia's leaving

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1560071501633798146

Vox getting harassed by chinks spamming him to graduate, Bilibili subs are in freefall

https://files.catbox.moe/9p1mvt.png

Iluna being a COMPLETE FUCKING SHITSHOW of clown hires, all flops too and mogged by Tempus
Nina leaking discord again showing she literally considers deleting and reposting tweets if they don't get enough "traction"

https://files.catbox.moe/hh34b4.png

Manager's name is Paul "of course its a chink, of fucking COURSE" Li

https://files.catbox.moe/hh34b4.png

yet another discord leak showing that the "we are such a happy family we love nijisanji" larp posts are LITERALLY ORGANIZED

https://files.catbox.moe/wvde1y.jpg

going all-out with the blatant peepee-poopoo "humor"

https://files.catbox.moe/zwoeqn.png
https://files.catbox.moe/jy2txb.png

Luca nukes like half of their entire minecraft server

https://twitter.com/SuppaPongo/status/1567714363628261377
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/44575965#p44585664

Enna says Kyo sounds like "he listens to Snoop Dogg and likes fried chicken", forced to do a 30 minute grovelling apology for it

https://twitter.com/meIomaid/status/1585489887620366336
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMiDa4DCsiE

Yugo gets unceremonially "graduated" (actually terminated) for no stated reasons

https://twitter.com/anycolor_inc/status/1602936545228783616

Kyo and Enna have an off-collab where they LITERALLY HOLD HANDS WITH INTERTWINED FINGERS, Enna later simultaneously tries to damage control the fact that she cucked her entire fanbase, and also makes fun of it with Kyo

https://files.catbox.moe/uhjmvb.jpg
https://files.catbox.moe/u0njsy.png
https://web.archive.org/web/20230103070525/https://streamable.com/hyow1l

Fulgur has to get axed from the planned NijiEN 3D concert due to "unforseen health concerns" (aka they realized he's LITERALLY too fat to fit into the mocap suit)

https://event.nijisanji.app/EN_COLORS/en/

The Yabbening

Everything between these lines happened in the span of roughly 2 weeks

Millie does a stream for a "secret group chat" that aims to parody /vt/ by "ironically" insulting her co-workers (who did not consent to this "joke" btw) with real criticisms, gets flamed by the entire fanbase for it, then tries to shift the blame when everyone calls her out

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/42025169
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zg2XZDyi7Vs

entire NijiEN 3D concert gets abruptly cancelled

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1621003847350235137

Luxiem openly calling out the bullshit Covid excuse for cancelling the concert on twitter with snarky vagueposts putting Covid in quotation marks and going "yeah sure"

https://files.catbox.moe/8x52vs.jpg

Shu later reveals that the cancelled concert has left him feeling "betrayed, powerless, lifeless" and he essentially took his streaming break because he was suffering from depression - in other words, Nijisanji is literally grinding the souls of their streamers into paste with their gross incompetence

https://files.catbox.moe/q089sc.png

EN either can't get Hogwarts Legacy perms or pretends not to have any because they're scared of a handful of twittertrannies
Zaion gets suspended for alleged lies, refusal to improve and "insensitive jokes"

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1623290561313783808

Kyo is caught throwing Zaion under the bus on his roommate account, damage controls as Kyo (???) once called out pretending he was talking about someone else, and takes a break from streaming because of his "internet"

https://files.catbox.moe/xgtxcm.png
https://streamable.com/ksabf6

Vox gets doxxed and exposed as not only having a girlfriend but also cheating on her, promptly goes into hiding in his cuckshed ("streams canceled indefinitely")

https://twitter.com/Vox_Akuma/status/1624069902179901442
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/42763770#p42764763
https://files.catbox.moe/bl5a5o.png

NijiEN's official twitter account fucks up linking the twitter handle of one of their livers, the wrong account then edits itself with dox info about Kyo, causing them to effectively dox their own chuuba. they only notice and fix it an entire day later.

https://files.catbox.moe/sr5tcc.png
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/42885982#p42887552

Elira has a meltdown over a horny 5$ SC and proclaims her audience aren't her friends

https://youtu.be/fsgIrvGgtGM?t=25815

AnyColor tries to take down dramatubers with illegitimate copyright strikes because of all the negative PR they've been getting, which not only gets even the normie internet to shit on Nijisanji, they also fucking FAIL to take down the videos

https://files.catbox.moe/0afgck.png
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5WZ3bSrdPKo
https://www.reddit.com/r/VirtualYoutubers/comments/1195d16/nijisanji_is_not_really_going_to_terminate_things/

Yabbening end

Prelude 2

Hex Haywire is a creepy groomer fuck who heavily copied Vox+Corpse Husband's parasocialbait shtick, larps as a THERAPIST to his (mostly underage) fans, encourages them to "traumadamp" him on streamlabs (pay up), likes selfies of his (mostly underage) on twitter, which are untagged meaning he stalks their accounts, and is completely unapologetic about all of it. Even the sisters are creeped out by him and made a google doc to document his actions

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Xsy85Cs38PTcDfPH19tw1hUg0VKCdkpL3icxmkjG0es
https://files.catbox.moe/2vcyoj.png
https://i.imgur.com/5TLCtSe.png

Kyo implied on his Doctor stream that grindr (gay dating app) is full of pedophile groomers, which is a huge no-no for the LGBT community (VOD deleted)

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/44647671#p44651976
https://gofile.io/d/uC1ViL

all of Ethyria starts OPENLY talking about politics more and more, freely chatting about free healthcare, green energy, immigration, "down with capitalism", you name it

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44748954#p44759533
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44748954#p44760348
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44600075#p44604622

Zaion gets publicly tarred and feathered in her termination listing every miniscule "crime" she ever did

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1634147534795841536

In the termination announcement Nijisanji reveals that she has been suspended since JANUARY, which was prior to her official suspension and actually when she allegedly took a "break", confirming the long-standing rumor that Nijisanji has shadow suspensions disguised as breaks

https://files.catbox.moe/u1t1ni.png

The entirety of Xsoleil torches Zaion after the firing, practically celeberating that she's gone, with Kotoka even saying she can't wish her farewell, meanwhile the entire NijiEN fanbase crucifies and harasses Zaion on twitter to the point of doxxing

https://files.catbox.moe/zttj1l.png
https://files.catbox.moe/51vedx.png
https://files.catbox.moe/hz1i44.png
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AtkQfYDZv-w

Zaion getting unperson'd to the point her name even got removed from the titles of the duet cover she did with Maria and the thumbnail darkened to hide her (+ comments turned off to hide complaints)

https://files.catbox.moe/rrik5y.jpg

Hex whips out a dildo asset mid-stream and his fans have a meltdown trying to "censor" the yab on twitter by spamming everyone to take down their tweets about it.

https://files.catbox.moe/fiiyaj.jpg

Nijishill admits to scripting a bot to shitpost Hololive threads because he's mad that Nijisanji is universally despised

https://files.catbox.moe/7zzulb.png
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/45362984#p45364057

Mirei Gundou gets indefinitely suspended for making a joke about baseball (seriously)

https://twitter.com/nijisanji_app/status/1638848081113522176
https://twitter.com/g9v9g_mirei/status/1638333072579104768

Nijisanji scams fans by "renewing" their birthday goods set to be much shittier yet keeping the same price, leading to huge outrage

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1639114816626528258
https://twitter.com/ewamatsu0304/status/1639126179172216832
https://files.catbox.moe/knea9f.png

Zaion's RM tells her story, reveals that Nijisanji:

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Vj88APlsr4J_4PTxqNb5zyUli13fXupzdRmEjTI-bhw/

It is discovered that Nijisanji Livers only make 1-3% off of their own merchandise, leading to mockery across the web (even kson chimed in)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IyynD83X-uI
https://twitter.com/ksononair/status/1656226203576188931

Nijisanji literally doesn't even let Niji livers own their Youtube Play Button

https://i.warosu.org/data/vt/img/0494/57/1684162427960711.jpg

Selen had to fight management just to be able to award prize money that's coming out of her own pockets for her art contest. AnyColor with the black company terms and conditions as usual

https://archive-media.palanq.win/vt/image/1683/72/1683724864988.jpg
https://i.warosu.org/data/vt/img/0491/38/1683729661276617.png

Ban Hada has a meltdown, shitting on his own fans and telling them to leave him alone because he doesn't want to stream

https://i.warosu.org/data/vt/img/0494/03/1684070433725270.jpg

Mysta has a meltdown, saying he's done with being a content creator catering to his fans and that he's just going to coast off doing whatever he wants

"Anyway, like you said: "how can you watch a guy who openly says he doesn't care about his content or how his fans feel towards it"; I don't know, you ask yourself that question and never come back here. If you don't like that- 'cause yeah, I don't care about my content, and I don't care about what my fans feel towards it. I don't. I have no reason to."

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/51003924#p51003924
https://www.youtube.com/live/VTZhZtLDDbc?feature=share&t=11074

Mysta also heavily references the corporations reputation being down the shitter.

"I dont need to represent the company, do you really think I'm going to ruin nijisanji's reputation? (laughs) ok dont make me speak anymore, I was going to say something prettyy bad. Bro, you can already infer what I was going to say, so who gives a shit, bro, who gives a shit"

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/51003924#p51005349

Entire new "gamer" wave gets leaked months before release by a disgruntled (likely now axed) member, asserts there were actually 3 members that got axed (and either replaced or planned as 6man wave), hence the delay of the wave

First Leak:
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/50126622#p50128331 (spoils official release date, leaks their PL's)
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/50126622#p50133783 (design leak)
Second Leak:
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/51396270#p51401569 (spoils mysta+rosemi hosting, claims 3 members in total were fired)
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/51396270#p51402248 (spoils the names)

Vox Akuma has a mental breakdown over his declining numbers, admitting he stays awake from depression because he'll never be as popular as he once was, says he has no clue why people enjoy watching vtubers, further admits he went from the doctor because of pains, who told him he's experiencing "physical manifestations of anxiety and stress". The guy is literally dying from the idea of not being popular anymore, wtf

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/51130985#p51133650
https://twitter.com/Vox_Akuma/status/1667575996017418240

Same leaker that leaked the Krisis wave also leaks Nina's graduation days before the official announcement, while saying another big one is happening soon

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/52151190#p52162629
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/52162728#p52162917
https://web.archive.org/web/20230630180905/https://twitter.com/NinaKosaka/status/1673344678534455298

Enna admits NijiEN is a sinking ship (third person to admit it after Selen and Mysta)

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/53196442#p53196442

Vox and Ike both simultaneously absent from their PROMISED AND SCHEDULED JPxpo 2023 appearance because "sorry lol, I forgot xD"

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1679447426149793793
https://twitter.com/ike_eveland/status/1679449297912315904
https://twitter.com/Vox_Akuma/status/1679447839078768641

Mysta graduates, confirming the leaker was saying the truth

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1683099645046833153
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/52162728#p52162917

Black corpo management axes Selen's projects for the 538th time

https://twitter.com/Selen_Tatsuki/status/1688922377097502720

Kotoka says she doesn't love being in Nijisanji, that "this place sucks" (but it's okay because she likes her genmates)

https://streamable.com/bus0q4

Luca has a meltdown over Nijisanji's terrible reputation and being considered a black corp, whiteknights and brownnoses them pathetically

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6bXvXu7ZVto

Millie has a meltdown over Nijisanji's terrible reputation and being considered a black corp, whiteknights and brownnoses them pathetically

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GqrsRdks08

The Yabbening 2

Everything between these lines happened in the span of roughly 1-2 months

Selen gets her Christmas MV taken down by Niji management shortly after release, prompting her to publicly call on her fans to reupload it. She is then hospitalized and stopped tweeting on her main account only to start tweeting on her PL account instead, leading to rumors of stealth suspension and graduation

https://files.catbox.moe/2hephj.png
https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/selen-tatsuki-fans-beg-vtuber-to-leave-nijisanji-after-cover-song-controversy-2445807/

Millie tries to throw Selen under the bus by "subtly" implying she is at fault and management dindunuffin wrong, a typical behavior from her recent strategy of sucking up to their management and white-knighting the corp

https://files.catbox.moe/rynngk.png

Pomu graduates, finally sick of constantly getting scammed and cucked out of any 3D opportunities by Niji's psychopathic management

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1743271163898556612

Bonus points for a rratGOD predicting it a week prior:
https://files.catbox.moe/5t4c0e.jpg

"Golden 20" (referring to the early NijiEN waves) starts flame wars on twitter, with some fans only caring about those and others bitching about those fans and how one should care about the newer waves too etc. etc., doesn't help that Aia fuels the fire with her inferiority complex (as if she wasn't part of why her wave flopped so hard lmao)

https://twitter.com/jinwooclips/status/1743276939912359941
https://twitter.com/HotaruFuruya/status/1743872341908860968
https://twitter.com/layze_san/status/1743841147934634468

Pomu's membership stream where she cried over Nijisanji destroying her "lifetime opportunity" gets taken down by management to hide the negative PR

https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/vtuber-fans-slam-nijisanji-for-privating-graduated-talents-emotional-stream-2494545/
https://www.reddit.com/r/VirtualYoutubers/comments/19dq8t0/nijisanji_ens_management_tries_to_hide_talents/

"#WhereIsSelen" starts trending on twitter after months of silence (obvious stealth suspension is obvious) from Selen after the Christmas MV fiasco (even Selen's artist chimes in)

https://www.dexerto.com/entertainment/selen-tatsuki-fans-fear-the-worst-after-vtubers-one-month-absence-2503001/
https://twitter.com/rpr/status/1752294038596698452
https://twitter.com/FlipsieVT/status/1751757772868260289
https://en.p2y.jp/vtuber-seren-tatsuki-illustrator-kamameshi-gogomaru-is-worried-about-her/
https://twitter.com/SimpaGator/status/1754134413200306448

Kyo graduates, clarifies it's NOT because of health reasons (another one bites the dust)

https://twitter.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1753055638429532383
https://twitter.com/kyokanek0/status/1753056961422123161

Uki has a meltdown over people gossipping about graduations/terminations and "who will be next" (gee maybe your shithole corp should stop losing vtubers)

https://youtu.be/9TqHSSMk97A
https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/68029228/

SELEN TERMINATION ANNOUNCED (gee who could have seen this coming?), obvious stealth suspension was obvious

https://x.com/NIJISANJI_World/status/1754459182412222481

AnyColor tries to their usual bullshit laundry list of "crimes" except they fuck up so hard that they self-incriminate and admit Selen TRIED TO SUICIDE/SELF-HARM OVER INTERNAL BULLYING while also admitting other livers may be involved (Selen never claimed this herself), while also admitting they were harassing her with calls while she was in the hospital and all around trying to paint her as the villain

https://files.catbox.moe/evmal0.png
https://files.catbox.moe/jm61c5.jpg

entire internet turns against them, even the Niji subreddit (normally intensely moderated with all criticism nuked) is on fire, Indonesian Wikipedia shits on Nijisanji, Selen's artist shows support for her, various content creators shitting on them, all of normie internet covers it

https://files.catbox.moe/c5m7fq.png
https://twitter.com/idwiki/status/1754491234771685720
https://files.catbox.moe/z3dm4m.png
https://files.catbox.moe/ggpvmp.png

MASSIVE boycott campaign from all sides: fan artists, content creators and een merchandise studios all blacklist Nijisanji in protest,, mass unsubbings etc. etc.

https://files.catbox.moe/pfj0v1.png
https://twitter.com/Game8910/status/1754564506330583463
https://twitter.com/studionekomata/status/1754525265663856780
https://twitter.com/itsjustfrel/status/1754538832957989302
https://twitter.com/weeniedesu/status/1754600196103938462
https://twitter.com/BeelzFlyLord/status/1754744145770369429
https://twitter.com/hytebrand/status/1755306063115788503
https://twitter.com/MofuMerch/status/1755606286337728855

Enna (one of the prime bullying suspects) has a membership coping stream where she tells her members not to "waste time digging for the truth" and that she could shoot someone and get away with it, additionally liking a reply that callously downplayed Selen's suicide attempt

https://streamable.com/26fzn3
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-yDiQTUf22U
https://twitter.com/_blubay/status/1755158408104145029

Luca's former head mod/secretary goes full scorched earth on Niji leaking a bunch of shit (mainly about how Luca vented about how 'unprofessional' the rest of Luxiem is for DARING to be upset about the 3D cancellation and trying to unionize against management) additionally that someone ILUNA was harassing the girl vtubers and making them uncomfortable, after some prodding reveals it was Aster

https://twitter.com/RazielWarmonic/status/1755265686224449640
https://twitter.com/RazielWarmonic/status/1755300116515176822

a mere hour later an anonymous post leaks a discord convo between Aster and Scarle where he is psychotically harassing her and angrily demanding answers and rejecting her apoloogies

https://files.catbox.moe/xqpy4e.jpg
https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/68446071/

Yabbening 2 end

Enna has so many yabs and instances of shitty behavior that they don't fit into the post:
https://rentry.org/rtz9g

the end of niji yab

Ennaschizo

archived from rentry.org/rtz9g

Back to TOC

The following was based on an original post by "Ennaschizo", I've added some stuff and some sources.
Enna's yabs are too numerous to name. I'll go through as many as I can remember.

The "Fried Chicken Incident"

had been using some racial jokes, gets in trouble for it
eventually says that Kyo (who talks like a black person) sounds like Snoop Dogg and likes fried chicken
forced to do a 30 minute grovelling apology

https://twitter.com/meIomaid/status/1585489887620366336
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMiDa4DCsiE

The "NTR Arc"

builds a character around being a lonely single woman craving penis
starts flirting with males in the company
First with Luca, doing a "workout stream". Brags about her ass, calls him "boss", and makes plans to meet up with him IRL.
Then releases her NTR themed outfit which is the "Queen of Spades". Cucks her fans in the VN skit abandoning them for a life with Kyo.
Invites Kyo over to her house, while laughing about her fans being cucks. Streams with him from her bedroom, holding hands with him, at midnight
aggressively flirts with Hex on twitter, asking him to choke her and smell his dick
starts flirting constantly with Diego on twitter even making plans to meet up IRL with him

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S41680491#p41680966
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44036452#p44037564
https://i.warosu.org/data/vt/img/0425/30/1675780071949842.png

The Parasocial Drama

gets criticism for being the "NTR vtuber"
starts trying to put distance between herself and chat
begins the toxic "platonically" meme
parasocial discussion engulfs twitter and even infects the JP branch
violates her own parasocial rules numerous times
blowing kisses to chat, calling her fans "hot", holding weddings with her fans
promises to give her chat regular "virginity updates" for when she loses her v-card

Povertybaiting

Enna constantly povertybaits and tries to give off the image that she's very poor to bait more donations

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44537600#p44538216

The Drama Arc

with her channel declining, Enna starts kicking up massive amounts of drama
ruins Selen's big wrestling tournament with her shitty behavior pretending to be tired
shits on Pomu's NKODice tournament too, saying she doesn't even want to be there
says extremely nasty and insulting things to Doppio, Mysta, and Ver
ruins 3 birthdays with her behavior, Petra, Mysta, and Kyo
is an extremely sore loser after being beaten by Ren in Mario Party
snaps at Zaion on twitter, forced to apologize when Pomu calls her out
rages at Elira on twitter in all caps because Elira didn't answer her phone
was the principle actor that sent the SecretGC stream off the rails to mock 4chan
repeatedly insults her fans in mean-spirited ways, practically every stream
openly admits she's a bitch a dozen times, says her streams are damaging people
rages at Kyo's superchatter who said that Kyo is too close to Enna

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S42027102#p42027784

Miscellaneous shitty things Enna has done

dramabaits her wisdom tooth surgery, even doing a will-writing stream
punches jesus in the face and laughs about it, professes a belief in chinese mysticism
constant donation baiting, pretending she's borderline homeless and can't pay her rent
insists she's a "weeb" because she watched Sailor Moon, is actually a normie
Selen is the only girl she left out of her intro, also refused to tweet Selen's 3.0 reveal
despite admitting her life is a complete mess, constantly tries to give her chat life advice
Makes a rape joke, says it's okay because she's a woman.
completely obsessed with trying to pass as a virgin, can't stand the fact that nobody believes her

https://files.catbox.moe/b71s6k.webm

Enna's Clique

3/4 of Ethyria were friends IRL since before joining, not a problem in itself except...
they ghosted+excluded Nina from everything like a bitchy highschool clique

https://streamable.com/32zdvc
https://archive.palanq.win/vt/thread/34666360/#34666360
https://web.archive.org/web/20220328222825/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0XktfsOoMI

Enna is also a complete SJW, she was doing the "fried chicken" bit for popularity

Constantly promoting gay stuff.
Repeating bluepilled nonsense like "intelligence isn't real"
doesn't want "genderfied" toys for children
repeats social justice nonsense about captialism and colonization
mocks white people repeatedly, especially hates them for being "rich"
refuses to move to America because she's scared of guns

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44407990#p44411187
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S44328972#p44336211
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S42203366#p42209331

Enna has been caught in numerous lies

says that she was lazy and dropped out of school, and her dad even fought with her saying she was wasting her talent. Later completely changes the narrative and says she was hired because of her "hard work", which is definitely not the case, she was a nepotism hire.
always tired for Saturday streams because she's out late partying Friday night, every week comes up with a new convenient excuse to explain it
says that she was lonely, but admitted this was a lie. Claimed that she only had friends in Niji but talks about meeting up with IRL friends practically every week
fake depression act which is nothing but a lie
fake poverty act to get donations

Enna being insulting towards literally everyone

Insults her father
Insults a loyal superchatter basically calling him an incel
Beats up a girl in school
Ruins Selen's big event when she (Selen) was coping with her grandmother's death
Ruins Millie's career by unrailing the Secret GC stream
constantly denigrates her chat

https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S43118384#p43121121
https://warosu.org/vt/thread/S42203366#p42209331

the end of ennaschizo

Back to TOC

Edited in June 2025 to add the linked rrat for archival purposes.

Edit
Raw PDF PNG
Pub: 16 Feb 2024 11:58 UTC
Edit: 20 Jun 2025 06:07 UTC
Views: 2174
new·what·how·langs·contacts