magni - 9/10, he gets really into the campy acting and the sound effects do fantastic work to elevate the scene, impressed by the maglord. no negatives, but being talked to like a child camper (ToT) might bother people since the other vps can easily be from a yume or bro's perspective
flayon - 4.5/10, i'm sorry flayflay but i don't understand your vp... he has the worst enunciation out of all of the voice packs and the direction of the story is bizarre, it feels like it was shoehorning itself way too hard to lead into axel's vp theme and therefore has nonsensical decisions made for you that would make flayon pretty sad in any real life situation, but it gives you some short time with flay so that's nice
axel - 7/10, slightly confusing story but he does a good job of making you feel like you're there with him and like you're having a real connection with him. kind of boring/overshadowed by the rest but not bad at all! dingo lovers will enjoy it!
vesper - 6.5/10, for a vesper voice pack he's putting quite a bit of vocal effort into it, i hated his valentine's vp but i feel like this would have been a perfect substitute for it. the sound effects do make me feel genuinely uneasy (read the vp title) but it feels like that was his intent so i'll give him back a point. rating is relative to vesper's vp history, if it were anyone else i'd rate it lower
altare - 10/10 (i also can't believe i'm rating this) features different facets of altare's personality, imo perfect for altyumes as it makes you feel like you're really there with him but it's not at all romantic, his sillykino side shines with the bgm and sound effects
bettel - 7/10 trying really hard to turn off the bias for this one... the vp script could have better fit the summer camp setting and do something less disjointed, there's nothing going on but talking, and there isn't a sense of you being inserted into the setting with him compared to the others. but he's genuinely a very entertaining voice actor and it's fitting for the jester himself, perfectly playing into a deluded ex-idol fantasy, jester LOVE
shinri - 9.5/10 it's another scary story youtube video upload but VERY intimate feeling, not in a sex way but like he's right next to you/on you, do not let momi download the vp or she will die. half point off for being the most straightbro unfriendly vp (seriously don't bother if his ASMR or yumebait stuff bothers you) and it's kind of just upcycled mama content but my GOD it's so well done that it barely matters
hakka - 5.5/10, confusing story within a story, and his latam voice acting/vocab/"probably" spam makes it feel disjointed, flayon please teach your man the power of proper inflection. but points for originality effort and kind of having ties to his lore theme