Needs input

Applications:
Vermillion - VR Painting
Open Brush
Bigscreen (do people still use this?)

FPS:
Onward (never fully recovered from being hacked up for a Quest 1 port)
Robo Recall (difficult to run on modern VR setups?)
After The Fall (light on content and kinda janky, a bit hard to recommend)
Lone Echo (difficult to run on modern VR setups?)
Sairento VR

Active Games: (needs a better name)
Creed: Rise to Glory (doesn't seem to be worth getting over Thrill of the Fight with dead multiplayer and no lobbies)
Vox Machinae (dead multiplayer, disappointing singleplayer)
To The Top (last updated 2017, don't remember even seeing it discussed)

Flight:
Ultrawings (should this be left in, replaced with the sequel, or completely dropped?)
Elite: Dangerous (tentatively planning to keep, but not sure about the state of the game these days)

Flat Game Ports:
The Forest VR (from what I remember this was pretty janky, and only really recommended since we had a group playthrough years ago)
Payday 2

Flat Game Mods:
Half-Life: VR Mod (supposedly had some issues, haven't tried it myself)
Doom 3 BFG VR
Alien: Isolation (early mod, no 6DoF, is this still relevant?)
gz3doom
Quake VR
Halo: Combat Evolved VR (is this really a long term rec or just fotm?)

Swords & Sorcery:
GORN (basic combat sandbox, worth playing now that B&S is complete?)
In Death (abandoned for Quest port, still worth it?)
Until You Fall
The Mage's Tale
Chronos
Dreadhalls
Herobound: Spirit Champion

Puzzles, Strategy, & Platforming:
Lucky's Tale
Brass Tactics

VN and Experiences:
Spice & Wolf VR (incredibly short)
Wilson's Heart (review seems pretty critical, never talked about)
Batman Arkham VR (super short)

NSFW: (I don't know anything about any of these, kind of inclined to drop them all and maybe link to Virt-A-Mate or something)
Honey Select VR
Koikatsu
CM3D2 VR
COM3D2 VR
VR Kanojo

Pretty much locked in for the final list

Introductory Demos:
The Lab

Utilities:
XSOverlay
Desktop+
OVR Advanced Settings
fpsVR
Steam VR Wheel

Social and Metaverse:
VRChat
Resonite
Rec Room (vouched for)

FPS:
Half-Life: Alyx
Boneworks
Bonelabs (new addition because of multiplayer)
Walking Dead: Saints & Sinners
Vertigo Remastered
Vertigo 2
Pavlov VR
Contractors
Breachers
Superhot VR
H3VR

Rhythm:
Beat Saber
Ragnarock
Synth Riders
Pistol Whip

Active:
Eleven Table Tennis
Thrill of the Fight
Walkabout Mini Golf (new addition, frequent lobbies)

Simulation:
Assetto Corsa
WRC (new addition, active rally club in thread)
Dirt Rally 2.0
Euro Truck Simulator 2

Flight:
VTOL VR
Project Wingman

Flat ports:
Skyrim VR
Serious Sam VR
Talos Principle VR
Fallout 4 VR (on the fence, but someone cared enough to make a modding guide, so it gets a pass)
No Man's Sky
Subnautica VR

Flat mods:
Vivecraft
Half-Life 2: VR Mod
Nomai VR (Outer Wilds VR Mod)
GTFO
Universal Unreal Engine VR Mod

Swords & Sorcery:
Blade & Sorcery

Platforming:
Moss

Puzzle:
The Last Clockwinder
I Expect You To Die
Paper Beast

Quest:
Resident Evil 4 VR
Lambda1VR

Planning to remove from the final list unless someone feels very strongly

Introductory Demos: (mostly irrelevant or unplayable on modern headsets)
First Contact
Toybox
Aperture Hand Lab
Nvidia VR Funhouse

Applications:
Google Earth VR
Microsoft Maquette (unsupported)

FPS:
Ghosts of Tabor (exfil zone in contractors showdown seems to be this but better)
Arizona Sunshine (should probably be replaced with updated remake)
Raw Data (unremarkable wave shooter)
Doom VFR (pretty much unplayable on any recent VR setup)
Dead Effect 2 VR (pretty barebones, is it still worth playing over other options)

Active:
The Climb
Sprint Vector (broken multiplayer)

Flight:
Aircar (tech demo)
Star Wars: Squadrons (dead multiplayer, issues launching)

Flat Ports:
ZONE OF THE ENDERS THE 2nd RUNNER : M∀RS (VR version supposedly has issues)

Flat Mods:
Dolphin VR (unsupported ancient version of Dolphin, not sure how usable this is anymore)
GTA V (unsupported, doesn't run well, bad VR implementation)
VRMod (Gmod VR, was only really noteworthy as a way to play HL2 before the mod released for that)

VRMMO:
Zenith: The Last City (dying off)

Swords & Sorcery:
Swords of Garguantua (possibly unplayable due to server shutdown)

VNs and Experiences:
Henry
Irrational Exuberance: Prologue
Dear Angelica
Gnomes & Goblins preview
Cosmic Sugar
Allumette
Realities
Fantasynth
Lost
Senza Pes
The Rose and I
The Cubicle

NSFW:
Waifu Sex Simulator (just for watching MMD animations?)
Sex Like Real (streaming app)
Monster Girl Island (unfinished patreon game)