Chapter 4
The morning passed with an uncomfortable near-silence between the two of them. Dawn suspected she knew how to help Lillie. Both times that she'd seen a girl having grown a penis, the way to change back had been to just use the equipment for its intended purpose. But every time she tried broaching the topic with Lillie, Dawn found herself struggling to think of a way to make the suggestion without sounding insane and embarrassing the shy girl to death in the process.
She imagined how the conversation would go. "Hey, Lillie!" Dawn would say. "There's no need to worry; I know how to fix you. You see, this same thing happened to me before, and it turns out all you need to do is stick that new dick of yours into a girl's ass or pussy, fuck her until one or both of you cums, and ta-da! You'll be fixed. And as a matter of fact, I know just the perfect partner for you. Her name is Dawn, and while she's only liked you as a friend up to this point, she actually really wants you to screw her brains out because watching Kiawe and Olivia fuck left her kind of hot and bothered, so why don't you just go ahead and..."
Even in her imagination, she looked and sounded like a crazy person. Regardless, Lillie had been so stressed out and uncomfortable that Dawn doubted the poor girl would even be able to get it up. Lillie wasn't the most confident person to begin with, but now that she'd been subjected to some kind of divine mutilation, she had been nothing short of a nervous wreck.
The two of them agreed that the best thing to do would be to return to Heahea City. They debated whether it would be best to bring Lillie to the Kahuna for guidance, or just take her to a hospital for a doctor's opinion. Both options meant backtracking to Heahea anyway, and at least there would be a comfortable hotel to stay at in the meantime. Dawn had the idea for her pokémon to Fly them back to town instead of going on foot, and while Lillie had been a little nervous to fly down from the mountain, this time the girl was so wrapped up in her own predicament that she didn't complain at all. At least the trip was short.
They checked into the hotel in the afternoon, with Lillie expressing her desire to take a nice long shower to try and calm her nerves. The man at the desk gave Dawn some funny looks, since she had now checked out and then back in to her room no less than three times, but it wasn't like she was breaking any rules or anything. She gave him a fairly generous tip to smooth things over, and she also made a point to remember the name on his little nametag. It was Jeff.
Since Lillie seemed to want some alone time, Dawn found herself with nothing to do in the city. She considered flying back to the volcano to try and challenge Kiawe again, but she didn't want to walk into an empty trial site again. She figured it would be best to let him know she was coming. The Island Chellenge hadn't required it up to this point, but then the last captain she'd challenged hadn't been in the middle of performing an unannounced ritual with the Kahuna.
Dawn asked the man at the desk how she could get in contact with Kiawe. Lana's contact information had been readily available, perhaps because the girl's trial site had been so close to town anyway. But Kiawe turned out to be harder to reach, and Dawn began to suspect that the captain might not even own a phone. It wasn't like it would work up on top of the volcano anyway. After the man at the desk asked a few other staff members if they had any ideas (and after Dawn had tipped a few of them a generous amount of poké dollars) the consensus was that Dawn should either go up to the trial site and wait for Kiawe, or ask the Kahuna how to find him. Dawn opted for the former, and decided to kill two Starly with one stone by bringing Lillie with her to talk to the Kahuna.
Dawn stopped to eat lunch first, giving Lillie a little more alone time to try and come to terms with herself. Afterward she marched up to Lillie's room and knocked gently on the door.
"Go away please," came the muffled voice from inside.
"Lillie?" Dawn inquired. "It's me. Are you all right?"
"No," Lillie said plainly. The girl sounded miserable.
"Can I... come in?" Dawn asked.
"Yeah, I guess," Lillie said after a long pause. There was a faint thump that sounded like the girl sliding off the bed, and a moment later the door was pulled open.
Lillie's blonde hair had been pulled into the elaborate ponytail that Dawn was used to seeing, indicating that the girl's impeccable grooming standards had not been affected by her gloomy state. But apart from that, she looked tired and utterly defeated, like she'd just found out that a pet had dies on the same day that she'd been expelled from school.
"I know what you're going to tell me," Lillie said, stepping back into the room so that Dawn could enter. "And if you say, "There's no need to worry!" then I'm not sure if we can still be friends anymore."
Dawn hadn't intended to say that, but there was a chance it could have slipped out. Lillie didn't sound all that serious about ending their friendship, but Dawn took the hint that now wasn't the best time for her trademark optimism.
"Look, we can fix you," Dawn said. "If it can be done then it can be undone. I'm sure of it."
"Do you have a legendary pokémon with you?" Lillie asked. "One that can overpower the guardian deities of Alola? Because if not, I don't know how else you can break this curse."
"We don't know for sure that it's a curse," Dawn reasoned. "It could be... a weird sort of blessing! Maybe in their eyes this is, I dunno, some kind of gift?"
"How is this a gift?" Lillie said. "I don't want a- um, a boy's parts down there. Why would anyone want that? It's disgusting."
"I'm pretty sure boys like having them," Dawn said. "They certainly like to talk about them a lot. And they sure like using them."
"Ew," Lillie said.
Again Dawn considered telling Lillie that she'd seen this all before, once as the transformed party and once on the receiving end, but her words caught in her throat before she could think of how to tell the story. While waking up with a penis had been a baffling surprise, actually using the thing with Lana had been a rush, and the memories of Lana wrapping her legs around Dawn weren't going to fade any time soon.
"Look, I know what we need to do," Dawn finally said. "We need to talk to Olivia. The Kahuna will know more about this curse, whatever it is. I bet she'll even know what we need to know to break it."
"How are we supposed to explain this to her?" Lillie lamented. "Do we just say I woke up one morning as a freak?"
"Hey, you're not a freak," Dawn said. "You're still you, no matter what you've got in between your legs right now."
Dawn's words of encouragement didn't seem to help much, and Lillie blushed harder at the passing mention of her new equipment. Dawn chose to ignore the reaction.
"Anyway," Dawn said, "I think I'm just going to tell her the truth. We were at the trial site unattended, we had a battle, and we were there when they did their ritual."
"Oh my gosh! Dawn, no! You can't just tell her you watched her and Kiawe, having..."
"I'm not going to lie to her!" Dawn insisted. "I know it's awkward and embarrassing, but the truth is all of this is embarrassing. I'm just going to come right out and tell her what happened. Even if she doesn't know what to do, I'm sure she'll know someone who knows someone who knows... something."
"And what if she doesn't believe you?" Lillie whined. "She's not going to take you seriously if you just walk up to her and say you were spying on her and now your friend got turned into... into..."
"Lillie," Dawn said, "she's going to believe me. We have really strong evidence with us."
"What do you mean?"
"You're coming with me, obviously. If Olivia thinks I'm lying, we'll just have to show her your penis."
"Eeww! No, Dawn! I am not showing this thing to anybody!"
"Why not?!" Dawn exclaimed. "Don't you want to get rid of it?"
"Aaarrgh...!" Lillie rubbed her palms into her face in frustration. The girl looked like she might literally die of humiliation right then and there. The idea of showing off her privates to the Kahuna was clearly too much for her to handle.
"You told me you'd met Olivia once before," Dawn said. "Unless she mistook you for a boy when you first met, she'll know this isn't just some elaborate cross-dressing prank. She'll know something's wrong with you. And I'm sure she can help us, one way or another."
There was a long pause before Lillie finally said, "All right... all right... fine. But let's go see her tomorrow. Right now I'm just exhausted."
With that, Dawn left Lillie alone for the rest of the evening.
Unlike the elusive Kiawe, everyone apparently knew where to find Olivia. Jeff, the man at the desk, told Dawn that the Kahuna's home was in Konikoni City, and that she also owned a jewelry shop there. The city was on a small island detached from the rest of Akala, and accessing it meant cutting through Diglett's Tunnel, which was a cave system that ran underneath the water. Once on the other side, Route 9 would take them directly to the city.
It took the whole morning to traverse the underground passage and the short Route 9. Once in Konikoni City, directions to Olivia's jewelry shop were easy to find. It helped that the store was actually just called "Olvia's Jewelry Shop." Dawn couldn't fault the woman for a lack of naming creativity. The straightforward title stood out in its own way.
A little bell rang as Dawn and Lillie entered the shop. A sign on the back wall said the store sold rare stones and fossils, an unusual thing to find at a jewelry store. A woman greeted them from a counter near the entrance.
"Sorry, we're not here to buy," Dawn said. "We're actually looking for Olivia. There's something urgent we need to talk to her about."
"I'm afraid she's not here," the shopkeeper said. "Olivia owns the shop, but it's not an everyday job. Usually she's too busy being the Kahuna."
"Oh no," Lillie said, "don't tell me we came here for nothing..."
"She lives in this city, doesn't she?" Dawn insisted. "Can you tell us where to find her? It's really important that we speak to her."
"I'm not about to give out my boss's home address," the shopkeeper said. "And before you ask, I'm not giving you her phone number either. If you need to speak to the Kahuna about official matters, be at the lighthouse tomorrow at sunrise. She holds, I guess you'd call it, a sort of open forum."
"Tomorrow?" Lillie balked. "I don't want to have to wait that long..."
"The Kahuna is a busy woman," she said with a shrug. "But she's not one to ignore people's troubles. I don't know if she's in town right now, but if you can find her, I'm sure she'll stop to listen to what you have to say. Otherwise you'll just have to wait like everyone else."
"It's only a day, Lillie," Dawn said. "Half a day, really. You'll be all right in the meantime. There's no need to worry."
"Argh, Dawn..." Lillie said, "I knew you were going to say that."
"One other thing," Dawn said to the shopkeeper. "Would you happen to know how I can get in touch with Kiawe?"
"The trial captain?" she said. "He was in here the day before yesterday, with Olivia. They were talking about doing something at the volcano. I'm not sure what."
"Does he come here a lot?" Dawn asked. "If you don't mind my asking."
"No, it's pretty rare for him to leave the trial site."
"That's strange," Dawn wondered. "I was looking for him yesterday, but he wasn't there to meet me. I was going to do his trial."
"Captains don't leave their trial site unattended for long, unless they're doing something important like a favor for the Kahuna. I don't know what he was doing with Olivia, and it's none of my business. But I imagine he's probably back at his post by now."
"Darn it," Dawn said. "I guess I just barely missed him. I'll have to go back there."
Dawn and Lillie politely excused themselves from the shop so they could find a place to stay the night. The city was primarily a merchant town and trading hub, but they were able to find a small hotel with an illuminated sign that read "VACANCIES." More importantly, a smaller sign below that indicated that the hotel rooms were air-conditioned.
"It's not that hot," Lillie remarked when Dawn pointed this out. "We aren't even at the peak of summer right now."
"Lillie, I'm from Sinnoh," Dawn said. "Sometimes we get snow in the summer. I'm not built for this climate."
The two of them walked into the office and asked about getting two rooms.
"You came just in time," said the man at the desk. "Someone just called to cancel their reservation. If they hadn't, I wouldn't have had any rooms available this evening."
"Wow, that's lucky," Dawn said. "Is the hotel usually this busy?"
"We're in the middle of tourism season, and there's a mineral exhibition nearby that's just wrapping up. Like I said, you're very lucky I had a room available at all."
"Please tell me it's a double," Lillie said. The girl was obviously uncomfortable at the prospect of sharing a room with Dawn.
"Not... technically," the man said. "The bed is queen-sized and there is... a... couch?"
"You can have the bed," Dawn offered. "I don't mind the couch. It's better than having to camp outside in this humidity."
"Thanks Dawn," Lillie said, sounding relieved as the man handed them their room key. They went to their room and Lillie neatly stowed her backpack in a corner, before lying down on the bed.
"I'm starving," Lillie said. "Do you think this hotel has room service?"
"I doubt it," Dawn said. "It's pretty small."
"I'm sure there are restaurants that can deliver or something. Do you want to order something?"
"Actually, I was going to fly back up to the volcano."
"What? Now? You can't be serious."
"The lady at the jewelry store said that Kiawe should be there," Dawn said. "Unless he's busy doing something else with Olivia. And I kind of got the impression that they were satisfied with each other yesterday."
"Gross, Dawn."
"So since we have time to kill, and I can get back to the volcano quickly, I'm going to go up there and do the fire trial."
"Why *now?" Lillie asked.
"Why not now? It's not like we have anything else going on."
Dawn didn't want to admit that part of her just wanted to see Kiawe again. She hadn't even really met the man since she'd only been spying on him. But she'd gotten along pretty well with the other trial captains so far, and this one had no qualms with showing off his sweaty pecs in the setting sun. So that was a plus.
"Did you want to come with me?" Dawn asked.
"N-no! Thanks, but um, I've flown more than enough for now. Maybe I can watch you do the next trial."
"Are you going to be all right by yourself?"
"Of course I am, Dawn!" Lillie said. "I don't need you to babysit me."
Dawn made it to the top of the volcano by early evening. This time, a pair of trainers were waiting near the wooden markers that flanked the entrance to the trial site.
"I've never seen a pokémon like that before," one of them commented after Dawn had landed. "Is that registered on your ride pager?"
"Don't need one," Dawn said simply. "Is Kiawe here? I'm on the Island Challenge."
"Oh yes," the trainer said. "Go straight ahead."
Dawn followed the path up to the arena, feeling oddly nervous this time. A part of her was worried that, somehow, the captain would know that this wasn't her first time here and deduce that she had been spying yesterday. The arena was much the same as it had been before, except this time the shirtless man with the stylish hair was standing in the middle of it, facing away from Dawn and staring off towards the sunset.
"I am Kiawe," he said, still not turning to face her. "My Marowak and I are students of the ancient dances that have been passed down in Alola for generations."
"You're a dancer?" Dawn asked. "I wouldn't have guessed." The man didn't look nimble or graceful enough to be a dancer, in Dawn's opinion, but she knew that looks could be deceiving. He certainly had stamina, at least enough to keep up with Olivia.
Ignoring Dawn's comment, the captain turned to face Dawn and continued his speech. "The trial of Kiawe... You will find that it is a bit different than the trials you have faced up to this point. But of course, you will attempt it, right?"
"I'm ready," Dawn said with a nod.
"My trial will test your powers of observation! There will be a dance, and then another. Your task will be to find the difference between the two. Begin!"
The trial involved three dancing Marowaks and was more of an observation puzzle than an actual test of skill. Kiawe had Dawn identify which pokémon was dancing differently from rendition to rendition, battling some of them in between rounds. At the end of it all, the totem pokémon appeared, and Dawn's pokémon was able to dispatch it with a couple of ground-type attacks. The trial was over quickly, and Kiawe seemed impressed by Dawn's skill.
"Whoa, spectacular!" Kiawe said. "With your keen observations, you were able to see even fine differences in our dances! And you defeated the totem pokémon with such ease!"
"Thanks," Dawn said, blushing from the captain's praise. "That went smoother than the last time I fought a giant pokémon on top of a mountain."
"Is that something you do often?" Kiawe inquired.
"No, um, not exactly." Dawn said. "And, um, I certainly haven't had a battle up on top of this particular mountain. The view is spectacular up here, by the way."
"It is, isn't it?" Kiawe said. "At sunset, it's like the sky is set ablaze by the sun. From this peak you can watch the heavens dance their celestial waltz like the guardian deities are throwing a gala in the sky."
"That's beautiful," Dawn said, not sure how else to respond as Kiawe waxed poetic.
"Anyway. You have earned this Z-crystal." Kiawe held out his hand as he approached Dawn, and she accepted the sparkling red stone with two outstretched hands.
"Thank you, Captain," Dawn said. "I will treasure this."
"And there is more," Kiawe said. "You may now use the ride pokémon Charizard. Charizard will lend you his strength, and you will be able to go anywhere you have been in an instant."
"Sorry, but um, I don't have a ride pager."
"You what?"
"They offered me one back on Melemele Island, but I said no. I'm not sure why, I guess I was just being stubborn. But I've gotten by without one so far." Dawn suppressed a nervous giggle, feeling a little embarrassed.
"Well. Hmm." Kiawe frowned. "I'm supposed to register a flying pokémon for you, but if you don't even have a pager, I'm not sure how you're going to get back down the mountain. Would you like for me to give you a ride?"
Dawn's eyes widened a little at his offer, but she tried to keep her composure. "I have a pokémon that can fly already," she said. "But that's so nice of you to offer! Maybe we can.... ride back down... together?
"Together?" he said, puzzled.
"Yeah! I mean, um, whenever you're done for the day. I figure when you're done holding trials, you go back down to civilization, right?"
"I do," he said. "Did you... want to come with me?"
"Sure!" Dawn said, a little too quickly. "I know we just met, but... you seem really nice. I'd like to get to know you a little better, y'know? Maybe we could... grab... dinner?"
"Are you asking me out on a date?" Kiawe said.
"I sure am!" Dawn said. "I'm sorry, I bet trial-goers don't normally do that. I don't know all the traditions in Alola. I'm a tourist, really. I hope that's okay."
"Do you think I'm stupid?" Kiawe asked.
"Um," Dawn began. "Sorry, what? No, I don't think you're stupid. Did I say something wrong?"
"You have been staring at my chest since the moment you came up here," Kiawe said. "I do not appreciate being objectified by a little Sinnohan girl."
"Wait, I'm not-"
"Who put you up to this?" Kiawe asked. "Was this Mallow? She's always trying to get under my skin."
"I wasn't-"
"Or was it Lana? You seem like more of her type." The man squinted his eyes and put on a faux accent as he said, "Moshi moshi Kiawe please fuck me with his big black peepee, desu!"
"What the fuck?" Dawn said, reacting like she had been slapped.
"I'm not interested," Kiawe said. "Please leave the trial site."
Dawn glared at the man for a moment, fuming. She debated whether it was worth it to try to explain that no one had sent her up here, and that her attempt to ask him out on a date had been genuine. Now she wasn't sure if she even wanted to try to patch things up with him, no matter how nice his muscles looked in the light of the setting sun.
"Fine," she said with a huff. Then she realized she was still looking at his chest, and forced herself to make eye contact with him. "But for the record, I was being completely serious, up until you started being a jerk!"
He opened his mouth to argue back, but Dawn turned her back on him, marching right out of the trial site before he could say a word.
"Wow, I can't believe he actually said that!" Lillie said.
Dawn had flown back to the hotel in Konikoni City to meet back up with Lillie. It was after dusk now, and Lillie had ordered a pizza to the room which they were now sharing on the couch. Dawn was a little surprised to find that "Alolan pizza" wasn't actually something that they had in Alola. But she didn't like pinap berries on pizza anyway.
"I know, right?" Dawn said through a mouthful of sauce and cheese. For once Lillie didn't cringe in response to Dawn talking with her mouth full. "I can't believe him. I was just trying to be nice, and he just blew me off in the rudest way possible!"
"To be fair, Dawn, if he said you had been staring at his chest, you, um... probably were. And that is kind of rude."
"He was dancing around without a shirt on!" Dawn said. "Literally dancing! I can't help it if a hot dude is just putting himself on display like that!"
"Maybe this is karma," Lillie said. "For you watching him, um... yesterday. You know?"
Dawn sighed, lowering the lukewarm slice of pizza. "Maybe. But it's not like he knew about all that. I'm sure he would have mentioned something if he had. I think he was just being rude."
"And kind of racist, too," Lillie said.
"Yeah, and that. What did he even mean when he said I was more like Lana? Was he just talking about how she has blue hair? Or is Lana Sinnohan too? I couldn't even tell."
"I think she's Alolan," Lillie said, "Not that it matters. I think he meant that you're, well... a little more like Lana than like Mallow. In some ways."
"What do you mean?" Dawn asked, taking another bite of pizza.
"Lana is... a little eccentric, you know? And she can be just a little bit blunt. Sometimes."
"Eccentric and blunt?" Dawn said, chewing. "Like me?"
"Well... no, you're not blunt, but... asking out a guy you just met like that, probably came across as more blunt than you realized."
"I'm not blunt," Dawn insisted. "I have all kinds of tact! Even if I do want to hump a guy!"
"Ew," Lillie said. "Did you really tell him that?"
"What? No, don't be ridiculous, I have more self-control than that. I was only going to let him buy me dinner. Or maybe buy him dinner. I dunno. And then maybe if we had hit it off, something might have led to something, and...?"
"Ew," Lillie said again. "I don't need to know what you do on a first date."
"That's not what I usually..." Dawn trailed off. "Ugh, never mind."
Dawn felt like Lillie was judging her a little harshly. While she was maybe guilty of lusting over Kiawe a little, Dawn felt that she'd demonstrated considerable tact throughout the day. She hadn't brought up Lillie's predicament since they'd left Heahea City, even though she strongly suspected that the solution to fixing Lillie's problem could be found right between Dawn's legs. But from the way she had explained the encounter with Kiawe, she probably sounded like a drooling fangirl from a bad anime, lusting over the hunky guy and begging him to romance her.
"There's no point dwelling on it," Dawn said, finishing her slice of pizza. "I did the trial, and I got the crystal. That means I just have to battle the Kahuna, and since we're meeting with Olivia tomorrow, I'm sure we'll be able to set up something so we don't have a repeat of walking into an empty arena."
"Do you think she'll be able to fix me?" Lillie wondered.
"No clue," Dawn said. "I don't think she's a..."
She paused for a moment, not sure what to call the woman.
"Is the term "witch doctor" racist?" Dawn wondered.
"What?" Lillie asked, puzzled.
"I used that term offhand a while back, and Lana kind of scoffed at it. Anyway my point is, Olivia isn't... that. But she'll probably know someone who can help, or know someone who knows someone. She's got to be the wisest person on the island, right? That's why they made her the Kahuna."
"Go back," Lillie said. "Why were you talking to Lana about witch doctors?"
"Oh, uh..." Dawn began, not sure how to explain. "We were talking about, uh... a, uh... problem? That... someone I knew...? Had?"
Lillie just stared at Dawn in confusion.
"It wasn't a long conversation," Dawn said. "Just... something came up. And then she helped me deal with it. It was over pretty quick."
For a brief moment, the memory of Dawn grinding her hips into Lana in the middle of the beach rose unbidden from the back of her mind. But she banished the thought – this wasn't the time.
"Well... that's weird," Lillie said. "Why did you two need a witch doctor? I don't even think those are a real thing on Alola. At least not anymore."
Dawn tried to think of how she could explain what she and Lana had been talking about, without telling the whole story from start to finish. She didn't want to explain everything to Lillie, but...
"Well, we, um..." Dawn mumbled.
She had been trying to think of a way to tell her story for more than a day now, and now Lillie was prompting her to spill the details upfront. There probably wouldn't be an opportunity like this again, and even though Lillie would probably cringe and cry "Ew!" at the mere mention of Dawn's escapades, knowing the full story and what it implied would probably be better for her in the long run.
"All right, Lillie," Dawn said, picking up the pizza box to set it on the little table by the couch. "I'm going to tell you a story and you have to promise not to freak out. I swear to Palkia that this is one hundred percent true, and the only reason I haven't told you before now is because I didn't know how to bring this up."
"Um, all right," Lillie said. "Go ahead, I guess?"
Dawn took a deep breath before beginning. "You aren't the first girl in Alola to wake up with a penis lately. I've actually seen this twice. And one of the girls it happened to... was me."
She let the sentence hang in the air to see how Lillie would react. For a moment, the girl just stared at her.
"You... have a...?" Lillie asked.
"Not anymore," Dawn said. "It went away on its own, after I used it."
"After you...?" Lillie squinted a little, putting the pieces together in her head. "Ewww. What does that have to do with what we were talking about?"
"Lana saw it," Dawn said. "I was sort of complaining about it, and that's when I mentioned witch doctors, but that part isn't important."
"All right..." Lillie said. It didn't sound like she necessarily believed Dawn, but she seemed willing to hear her out. Dawn took another deep breath before continuing.
"It got hard after I finished Lana's trial. I don't know why; maybe it was the adrenaline, or maybe it was just from the rocking motion while I was on the water. But Lana saw it, and she offered to help me, well... take care of it."
"Are you... saying Lana is a witch doctor?" Lillie asked.
"No, I..." Dawn groaned slightly, shaking her head. "Forget about the witch doctor, that part wasn't important. Lana knew I had rode my bike to get there, and she offered to help me get rid of my, uh, problem, so it wouldn't be in the way while I tried to ride my bike."
"I'm confused," Lillie said. "How would it get in the way on a bike? And how did Lana... get rid of it?"
Dawn realized she wasn't being blunt enough. "Lillie. I had a boner. And Lana let me fuck her."
"Ew!" Lillie said.
"Stop saying ew, you prude! It was perfectly, natural consensual lovemaking between two enthusiastic partners."
"And that made it go away?" Lillie asked.
"The penis didn't go away instantly," Dawn said. "Sex made my boner go away, obviously, and then I went back to the hotel for some rest. When I woke up, I had my pussy again."
Lillie looked like she was about to say "ew" again, but she stopped herself.
"I guess I can't prove any of that happened," Dawn said, "So you'll just have to take my word for it. It's not like I would make something like this up."
"No, um... I believe you," Lillie said. "If this hadn't happened to me too, I don't know if I'd be ready to believe it. But having been a victim of the same thing, well..."
Dawn felt a sense of relief. She knew that Lillie could be a little stubborn, in her hapless way, and she was just glad that the girl had believed her without demanding some kind of evidence. She supposed she could have called Lana to corroborate her story, but that would have been a very strange conversation.
"You said you've seen this twice?" Lillie asked. "Who was the other person?"
"Mallow," Dawn said simply. "I don't know her entire story, but she said she woke up with a dick about a week before I met her. She was able to get rid of hers too."
"And how'd she do that?"
In response, Dawn just stared at Lillie and raised her eyebrows.
"Oh," Lillie said. "Wow, um."
"Yeah," Dawn said, not wanting to go into too much detail. "We did the deed, and she told me she changed back to normal the morning after."
"Why did this happen to you?" Lillie wondered. "And why Mallow? And why me?"
"I have no idea, Lillie."
"I thought we did something to offend the Tapu," Lillie continued. "I just assumed that was why they cursed me. But why would they mess with you and Mallow?"
"I don't know," Dawn said again. But then she thought about the details for a moment, a puzzle piece falling into place. "Mallow said she woke up with a penis about a week before I met her. That means she probably grew hers around the same time that I got mine. Maybe the two events were connected?"
"That doesn't explain my, um, thing," Lillie said.
"No, but... this might be something else we should ask Olivia about. It had to have been magic or something, right? Surely the guardian deities are involved somehow. Do they often mess with people's junk?"
"I don't know," Lillie said. "Maybe. I know sometimes they like to mess with people in general."
"And why would it go away after it'd been used?" Dawn continued. "Mallow had hers for longer than I did, so it can't have been a time thing. And when she came in my mouth-"
Lillie blushed a deep shade of scarlet.
"-that didn't do anything, at least not right away. It was only after we had sex that she finally changed back. Maybe all that the Tapu wanted was for us to have sex, for some reason."
"Well," Lillie said, "that would explain why they gave you a, uh, thing. It's not like two girls could have sex."
"Heh, very funny," Dawn said. But then she realized Lillie was being serious. "Maybe, uh... the Tapu's lust isn't quenched by scissoring. That's not really my thing either."
"Scissoring?" Lillie asked, with genuine sincerity.
"That's when two girls, uh..." Dawn mimed the position with both hands. After a second or two, Lillie seemed to understand.
"I get it," she said, gesturing for Dawn to stop. "So with all this, what you're telling me is, if I use this thing with a girl, it'll go away by itself?"
"I don't want to promise anything," Dawn said. "I'm not the Kahuna. I don't know the lore or whatever. I won't pretend to know why the Tapu did this to you, or why they left me alone this time. All I know is what I've seen so far."
"I've never had sex," Lillie said. "At all. Not with this thing, not with my, um... not before. I fooled around with a boy I knew, a little bit, but that was all."
This came as no surprise to Dawn, but she didn't want to be mean to the sheltered girl. From what she'd told Dawn about her life, it was surprising that she'd even had the time to "fool around" with anyone.
"Do you... want to?" Dawn offered.
"With who?" Lillie asked.
"With me, obviously," Dawn said. "I think I'm the only one who understands your predicament. And we're friends, aren't we?"
"I thought you liked boys," Lillie said. "Big, buff, tan-skinned men with dyed hair and..."
"Screw Kiawe," Dawn said. "I do like boys, but... Alola has been opening up my mind to some new experiences lately. Y'know?"
"What if I make a fool out of myself?" Lillie asked.
"Oh, you will definitely make a fool of yourself," Dawn said with a chuckle. "Everybody does, and it's fine. The first boy I was with took ten minutes to put the condom on, and then I kind of grabbed his balls too hard and he couldn't keep it up anymore. We were both a pair of fuckups. Everybody is on their first time."
"Oh, we need a condom..." Lillie said. "I don't have one. Um, obviously."
Dawn's mind wandered back to what she'd seen yesterday between Olivia and Kiawe.
"...don't worry about that," Dawn said. "I know how to make your first time special, and it'll take care of that problem too."
"Um... all right, well, you seem to be the one who knows what she's doing," Lillie said. "How do we start?"
Dawn chuckled, standing up from the couch. She reached out her hand to take Lillie's, leading her over to the bed and gesturing for her to get onto it.
"Lose the skirt," Dawn commanded. Then she followed suit herself, sliding the pink garment down her hips. Lillie obeyed, sitting down to undo her own skirt and sliding it past her legs. Dawn could already see the girl standing fully erect, the girl's white cotton panties barely holding the penis back.
"You look like you're almost ready to burst," Dawn commented as she slid her own underwear off.
"You were talking about sex stuff," Lillie said. "It just happened on its own."
"Naughty girl," Dawn teased, as she motioned for Lillie to slide up the bed to make room for her. "Take off those panties and let him breathe."
"Don't call it "him" please," Lillie pleaded. But she complied with Dawn's request, sliding her underwear down past her smooth, pale thighs as Dawn climbed onto the bed as well.
"Don't take this the wrong way," Dawn said, "but this is probably going to be quick. I didn't last very long with Lana, and I'm told most boys don't last long during their first time either."
"I'm not a boy," Lillie insisted.
"Sorry," Dawn said. "Most, um... penis-havers don't last long their first time." As she said this, she carefully climbed on top of Lillie, resting her posterior near the girl's knees.
"Good," Lillie said. "I just want to get this over with. This is so gross..."
"Oh, you say that now," Dawn said smugly, reaching a hand out to wrap around the girl's cock. Lillie inhaled sharply as Dawn touched her member for the first time.
"Oh, don't touch it..." Lillie groaned, not really meaning it. "Just put it in, please."
"You can't just shove it in," Dawn said, reaching between her legs to find that she was hornier than she had realized. "Remember that for whenever you have your first time for real. The girl has to be ready, or else it'll just hurt."
"Nnmm, Dawn..." Lillie mumbled, "Is that why you're playing with it?"
A bead of precum was already forming on Lillie's head, and Dawn realized the girl was probably a lot hornier than she was, even though she'd been too shy to be up front about it.
"Don't act like this doesn't feel good," Dawn said, still fingering herself as well. "Lana kind of teased me when we did it. I know I enjoyed it."
She stroked Mallow carefully, rocking her hips gently in time with the motion, like she was already riding her partner. Lillie buried her face in her hands, breathing heavily as Dawn jerked her off, clearly lost for words.
"Would it make you feel better if I said yours is cuter than Mallow's?"
"Oh, god, Dawn, I don't even know," Lillie mumbled. "Are they even supposed to be cute? The only time I really saw one was when I walked in on my brother."
"You have a brother? Is he cute?"
"I don't want to think of my brother right now," Lillie whined, moving her hands away from her face. "Is this what you talked about with Mallow?"
"Mallow... just kind of used me," Dawn said, deflating a little. "I wouldn't want to do something like that to you."
"Dawn," Lillie said, putting her hand on Dawn's as it was wrapped around her cock. "There's no need to worry. You're trying to fix me. If anything, I'm the one using you. Thank you."
Dawn smiled, a pang of gratitude warming her heart. The circumstances were so bizarre – to have a partner in bed thank her just for the opportunity to get a light handjob. They'd hardly even done anything yet.
"Thank me when we're done," Dawn said, sitting up on her knees so she could position her hips over Lillie's stiff cock. She rubbed her lower lips all over the girl's head, and they both gasped a little now that they were making contact.
"Wait, Dawn," Lillie said. "I know we need a condom..."
"No we don't," Dawn said as she slid forward a little, lining Lillie up with her back door and doing her best to spread herself with her other hand. Then she began to sink down gently onto the stiff intruder, and seconds later Lillie was no longer a virgin.
"Aaahh..." Lillie gasped with pleasure and confusion. "What are you...?"
"Nngh," Dawn grunted. "It's tight."
She sank down a little lower. It was an intense sensation, not exactly pleasurable, but not quite painful either. She knew she had to go slow, remembering how rough and forceful Mallow had been with her. She was pretty sure that the only reason Mallow hadn't left her screaming in pain was because the girl had changed holes right as Dawn was cumming.
"So hot," Lillie mumbled, "Oh my god, Dawn... You're so tight, this is... oh my god..."
"Yeah," Dawn said, feigning confidence. Her fingers started to work her clit, and she tried to imitate what she'd seen Olivia doing with herself the previous day. It felt good, but her ass was also starting to hurt.
"What should I...?" Lillie wondered, not sure what her role was in all this.
"Let me get used to it," Dawn said as she lifted her hips back up a little. "If you just thrust into me, it'll hurt."
"All right," Lillie said obediently. Dawn could sense a tension in the girl, like she wanted to jerk her hips up into her partner, but Lillie seemed too overwhelmed to act upon it. Dawn did her best to spread her ass with one hand, sinking back down onto the girl, the hot member intruding uncomfortably into her hole. Her pussy was dripping wet now as she rubbed fierce little circles into her clit, her aching hole not sure what to do with itself as it craved the attention her back door was receiving.
"Kind wish..." Dawn muttered to herself, "There was... two of you or something..."
"Hngh..."Lillie said suddenly, "Dawn... I'm gonna... aagh!"
With Lillie more than halfway inside Dawn's ass, a hot sticky sensation suddenly filled her hole and the extra lubrication allowed Lillie to slip the rest of the way in. The deeper penetration and the hot cum hurt more than they felt good, and Dawn let out a little yelp.
"Oh god," Lillie gasped, "I think I just... I'm..."
"Go on, let it out," Dawn muttered as she tried to accommodate the cock twitching balls-deep inside her ass. She was a little disappointed that it was over so quickly, but she had known what she was getting into.
"Hnngh," Lillie grunted as she reached her peak, quivering beneath Dawn as she filled her ass with cum. Several more spurts of hot sticky goo shot into Dawn's ass before Lillie finally went still, breathing heavily. Dawn tried to focus on her other hole, but the stinging sensation of her ass being pried open wasn't feeling any better as the cum started to ooze out around the intruder, and finally she gave up.
"Wait," Lillie gasped, looking up at Dawn. "I just... inside you... without...!"
Dawn realized Lillie hadn't even been paying attention to which hole she was in. But as the last weak spurts of cum drained out from the girl, Dawn lifted her hips gently and allowed Lillie to slip free from her ass.
"That wasn't my pussy," Dawn said. "I told you I'd make your first time special.
Lillie's eyes widened with disbelief. "Did I just... in your... behind...?!" she stammered.
"Yeah," Dawn said with a little smugness. "Was it good for you?"
"I don't... I mean, it felt really good, obviously, but... what about... you...?"
"Mallow said that was supposed to feel awesome," Dawn said, "and Olivia looked like she was cumming her brains out."
"You're acting like it, uh... hurt," Lillie said.
"A little," Dawn admitted. "Maybe I didn't do it right. I've got two holes for a reason, don't I?"
"I'm sorry," Lillie said impulsively. But Dawn just laughed a little.
"Oh, no, don't apologize Lillie! You did your part, I just... thought anal was a little more exciting."
"That wasn't exciting?" Lillie wondered off, her eyes wandering to the spot where Dawn's hips were still hovering over her cum-stained cock, her member already having shrunk halfway down to its normal state.
"I told you I wanted to make your first time special," Dawn said. "And it was my first time, too... sort of."
"What happens now?" Lillie asked.
"If this is anything like the last two times," Dawn said as she climbed off of Lillie, "you'll be back to normal in the morning."
"And you're sure?" Lillie asked.
"I'm not sure," Dawn said, "but that's what I've seen. In the morning, if you still haven't changed back, we'll go talk to Olivia and find out how to break this curse."
Dawn excused herself to the bathroom to clean herself up, walking a little unsteadily from her sore asshole. She took a nice long shower, getting a little distracted as the hot stream poured down her body. She imagined she was back on top of the volcano, kneeling on top of a naked Lillie, with Kiawe standing at the ready. She lined her pussy up with Lillie's waiting cock, letting it sink a few inches into the tight folds of her pussy, pausing so that Kiawe could get into position behind her. Then Kiawe got onto his knees and worked his dick gently in between her asscheeks, burying himself a few inches just slowly enough for Dawn to adjust. Then Lillie thrust her hips upward and Kiawe started ramming into her from behind, and they both fucked her like desperate animals while she hung half-limp in their grasp, losing her mind in waves of ecstasy as twin cocks fucked her little holes to the absolute limit before they finally burst two thick loads into her pussy and ass, all three of them screaming in a climax that lasted for an eternity...
She felt a lot better after jilling off in the shower. Maybe anal wasn't all it was cracked up to be, but the fantasy would probably be with her for a long time.